You are not logged in. You can log in or create an account to save favorites and join collections. more info
Dana Paramita: The Perfection of Generosity
Mei Elliott explores generosity as one of the Six Perfections, focusing on the relationship between generosity and liberation through an investigation of the the Four Noble Truths.
The talk presents dāna (generosity) as both a practice that carries beings from delusion toward awakening and a direct means of loosening craving and clinging; in keeping with the principle of simultaneity, generosity also offers a taste of freedom in the present. It emphasizes mindful giving, compassionate attention to one’s own stinginess, and appropriate boundaries, while locating the perfection of generosity in understanding the emptiness of giver, receiver, and gift.
Texts and teachings referenced
- The Four Noble Truths — Frames suffering as rooted in craving and presents the Eightfold Path as the way toward its cessation; generosity serves as a practice of release.
- The Heart Sutra — Its teaching that the aggregates are empty supports the discussion of clinging and the emptiness of the three wheels of giving.
- Advice to Rāhula — The Buddha’s instruction to attend to actions before, during, and after informs the practice of mindful giving.
- An early Buddhist sutta on clinging and the notion “I am” — Links clinging to form, feeling, perception, formations, and consciousness with the arising of self-view.
- Śāntideva’s verses on the bodhisattva vow — The closing verse depicts the bodhisattva as a boat, raft, and bridge for beings crossing the flood.
- The Jātaka tales — Cited as examples of bodhisattva generosity, alongside a caution against giving beyond one’s means.
- Frederick Buechner’s account of vocation — Describes vocation as the meeting of personal gladness and the world’s need, relevant to giving that benefits both giver and others.
- Jaya John’s writing on boundaries — Offers an image of boundaries as a steady light affirming the need for respectful treatment.
- Ajahn Chah’s teaching on clinging — Emphasizes recognizing clinging, including when letting go is not yet possible.
Speakers referred to
- The Dalai Lama — The translation of Śāntideva’s verse recited at the close is identified as one recited daily by the Dalai Lama.
- The Buddha — Cited for teachings on the monkey-like mind, the Four Noble Truths, mindful action, and clinging.
- Ānanda and an elder monk — Their exchange illustrates how clinging gives rise to the notion “I am.”
- Ajahn Chah — Referred to for the teaching that spiritual practice often involves recognizing clinging before being able to release it.
AI Suggested Title: Generosity as a Taste of Freedom
This podcast is offered by the San Francisco Zen Center on the web at www.sfcc.org. Our public programs are made possible by donations from people like you. Good evening, everyone. My name is Mae Elliott. I'd like to start by thanking Abbott David for inviting me to the practice period and to give this talk. As many of you know by now, the word paramita, I like to think of it as an ancient Sanskrit pun, which can be translated as both perfection and crossing over, crossing over to the other shore, from the shore of delusion to the shore of awakening. So I was thinking about this image of crossing over to the other shore, and a memory came to mind. In this memory, it was in my early 20s. I went to India.
[01:00]
And when I was there, I visited a lot of different cities, one of which was Rishikesh. And I remember one afternoon, I had the opportunity to hitch a ride on the back of a motorbike upriver on the Ganges to what was supposed to be a secluded beach. So I did. Got there. And when I arrived, there was a lovely little sandy beach, nobody else there, a rocky outcroppings and boulders. So I set down my backpack and I climbed up the boulders, a lay of the land, just in time to look down and see that there was a monkey unzipping my backpack, which happened to contain my lunch. So I scurried down from the boulder. And kind of shooed the monkey away, which happened to get the attention of all the other monkeys in the area. So they came to check out what was going on.
[02:02]
And what I thought at first might just be simple curiosity, started to look a little bit more like aggression. So kind of encircled me. except it wasn't that it was a circle because the rapid-filled Ganges was behind me. So they were slowly backing me into the river until I was on this tiny little sandbar that was maybe only three feet from the shore, just not a safe distance. I had a stick. It was pathetically unthreatening to them. And as moments went by, I thought I might become lunch, until... To my great surprise and amazement, a raft appeared from upriver and the boaters picked me up kind of the way a mother cat picks up a kitten and threw me into the raft and then safely delivered me to the other shore.
[03:04]
So I got lucky in that case. And I think to a certain degree we all find ourselves trapped on the shore of delusion at times, suffering on a particular shore. And it may not be that you have literal monkeys that you're working with, but chances are something that keeping you on the shore of delusion is your monkey mind. And this term monkey mind, it sounds a lot like a modern invention, but it's actually hearkening back to an analogy that the Buddha used. this analogy of the mind being like a monkey, and particularly a monkey swinging through the jungle. So when a monkey is swinging from tree to tree, you've probably seen this or seen footage of it, while still holding one branch, they reach and swing and grab hold of the next, often before they've let go of the first one, then on to the next and the next, grasping one branch and then the other.
[04:08]
And this is a lot like our thinking. Before we've even put down one preoccupation, we're already reaching for the next. We're already grabbing hold of the next one. So how then do we move from the shore of delusion to the shore of awakening? How do we cross over? So for me, it was an act of generosity. that helped me cross over from one shore to the other, some very benevolent boaters. And my hope for this evening is to share ways that you might also understand that generosity is a way for you to cross over from one shore to the other. So needless to say, tonight's talk is about dana. That's the Sanskrit and Pali for generosity, this term. And just to say briefly, the paramitas as a whole, the six paramitas as a whole, they function as a list of these six qualities that we cultivate as bodhisattvas in our bodhisattva training.
[05:24]
So these are qualities that guide us on the path to awaken for the benefit of all beings. So I'd like to remind you of a parable that David shared. at the very beginning of the practice period, because it's pertinent to what I'm sharing tonight. So in it, there's a student and a teacher. I'll give you the abridged version. The student and a teacher, the student's on one side of a river, the teacher's on the other, and she yells across, how do I get to the other shore? And the teacher replies, you are on the other shore. So I love this, in part because it points to something that's so wonderful about the Paramitas. So on one hand, the Paramitas, they provide us with a map, a map to awakening to the other shore. When cultivated, they help us traverse from delusion to awakening. But simultaneously, they manifest the complete fulfillment of the path.
[06:28]
Here and now, on the very shore that we're standing on, there's freedom here. You can experience that here and now. And there's a term for this, and the term is the principle of simultaneity. So the idea is that the ends are in the means. We don't have to wait until the end of the path to taste happiness and to taste freedom. It's all along the way. This is one of the reasons that it's said that the dharma is good in the beginning, good in the middle, and good in the end. I personally find that the principle of simultaneity is quite palpable with generosity, and that's one of the reasons I wanted to mention it. We don't have to wait until the end of the path. So with generosity, it's kind of like we get a foretaste of freedom here and now. We can feel a sense of joy, a sense of interconnection, just in the act of giving.
[07:35]
And on the flip, there's a reason why the word miser is etymologically related to the word miserable. So giving leads to happiness. Miserliness does not. So it may be obvious to you experientially that being generous, generosity, it brings forth joy or happiness or feelings of goodness. But I'm not sure that it's always clear to people how that works or why that is or how that's functioning. So there's a number of reasons that generosity leads to happiness, of course. And there are a number of reasons that it gives us that foretaste of freedom. I'd like to speak about one, to talk about one of the ways that this functions. And in doing so, my hope is also to give you—just to underscore why generosity is such a foundational teaching in Buddhist thought.
[08:45]
So part of the reason that generosity provides this foretaste of freedom, and one of the reasons it's so foundational, is because it's a direct antidote to craving and cleaning. So to practice generosity, we're practicing a form of letting go. And that act, that act of giving, then undermines the habit of mind that craves and clinks. So that's the synopsis, but I want to unpack that a little bit, particularly for those who might not be as familiar with the relevance of craving and clinking. I mean, why is that a big deal? What's important about that? So... Yeah, let's talk about the four noble truths. So the first truth, there is suffering. The word is dukkha. There is dukkha, and this word can be translated as suffering or unsatisfactoriness or stress.
[09:47]
And it speaks to that whole spectrum of slight unease, the greatest difficulty a human could experience. Second noble truth, the source of suffering is craving. The word is tanha, technically thirst, insatiable thirst. And so craving, the other side of the same coin, is aversion. So craving aversion, two sides of the same coin. Or we could say the source of suffering is wanting and not wanting. And while that teaching is quite familiar, I think that teaching is shared commonly, that it's always clear why that is. So why is craving and clinging suffering? What's that about? Well, if we look a little more closely, we find that the habit of mind that wants, that craves, and whatever it is, whether that's an object or a person or a place or an idea, whatever it is, the craving, the clinging, it carries an underlying message.
[10:56]
the underlying message is something along the lines of, this moment isn't quite right. It's like desire has this secret message. This moment is not enough. And so just embedded in that habit of mind, there's a dissatisfaction. So this unwholesome desire, it has this... this element of discontent embedded in it. Now, the tricky thing is 99.9% of humans, probably more, don't tend to notice when craving and aversion are present. So instead, we think that we're suffering because our job is too difficult or because the neighbor's dog barks in the middle of the night or because of that one difficult person in our life. So we don't tend to notice the craving or aversion that's the acting principle beneath the suffering that's taking place there.
[12:06]
We're so mesmerized by the objects of our wanting and not wanting that we don't see that craving and aversion are going on under the hood. So all to say, in daily life, These habits of mind are happening so often, but we don't tend to see them because we're so fixated on objects, situations, people, things. We're so fixated on the job or the barking or the difficult person, we don't see what's happening beneath. So that's the significance of the second noble truth, that, oh yeah, suffering comes from wanting and not wanting, from craving. Third noble truth, There is an end to suffering, the end of craving and clinging, or we could say the end of greed, hatred, and delusion. Very simply, just the end of craving. Fourth noble truth, the path to the end of craving, the noble eightfold path.
[13:09]
So we have these two sets of causal relationships. We have suffering and the source of suffering, craving, and then we have awakening. and the source of awakening, the Eightfold Path. So what does this have to do with the paramitas and generosity? So when we speak about crossing from the shore of delusion to the shore of awakening, when we talk about crossing the great flood of samsara, if we look at the Four Noble Truths, it's like the great river of samsara cuts right down the middle. On one shore, we have the first and second noble truth. We have suffering and the cause of suffering, craving. And on the far shore, we have the third noble truth, awakening, the end of craving, the end of suffering. So this is what we're learning to traverse with all of the paramitas, and tonight, particularly with generosity. So generosity, it carries us from the shore, the first and second noble truth, the shore of delusion,
[14:16]
to the shore of awakening with this process of letting go. So generosity, when we enact it, we're practicing release, we're practicing renunciation. So this is that habit of mind that lets go. So we can see how that developing that mental habit is a direct antidote to the craving and clinging that lead to suffering. So they can carry us this this quality of generosity can carry us from one shore to the other. And even just one act of generosity, in one act we can have a taste of that far shore. And that is the principle of simultaneity in action. There are a lot of different ways that we could talk about giving generously. all the different types of things that can be given, the different ways to practice it.
[15:21]
I'd like to share one story of generosity that stood out to me. And this is a news clipping from a few years back. From 10 p.m. to 7 a.m., that's 10 p.m. to 7 a.m., Henry Darby works the overnight shift. stocking shelves at his local Walmart in South Carolina. When morning comes, he heads to his day job as a high school principal. Every penny from his Walmart paycheck goes to his students, 90% of whom live below the poverty line. This is from Darby. I get a little emotional because when you've got children you've heard are sleeping under a bridge or a former student and her child sleeping in a car, he said with tears in his eyes. At my age, you just go ahead and do what you need to do. Darby, not one to seek accolades, said, I don't think I've done anything worthy of distinction to warrant the attention.
[16:30]
He simply hopes his students, whom he calls his grandchildren, will pay it forward. He says, it's quite simple. Just learn everything. to help others. That is one of the greatest things that we can do in terms of being human. Many people associate generosity with material gifts. And Darby, Henry Darby, expresses generosity in so many more forms. Material giving, but also with time and attention and love. So generosity can manifest in many, many different ways. And we could give a whole talk on just the different ways that generosity manifests. But what I'd like to turn towards a little bit more is how to practice with the actual act of generosity. When we give a gift, how are we practicing in that moment?
[17:32]
So the invitation, as with everything that we do, is to be really present, to be really mindful when we engage in generosity. So if you're going to give a gift, can you be present? Can you be aware before, during, and after the giving? So if you were at the talk here on Saturday by Pam Weiss, when you hear before, during, and after, that may ring a bell. That's the Buddha's advice to Rahula, his son. She shared about that a couple of days ago. So we're observing what's happening for us. Before we give a gift, what's our intention? I remember a time in college, I was making a lot of pottery, and I gave somebody a vase that I made. And I'd say maybe like 80% of the intention was to just give them something that I knew they'd enjoy and make them happy, and I felt some delight in that. And maybe like 20% was that I wanted them to think I was a good potter.
[18:37]
So it was really helpful for me to see that, to see what was happening with the intention. And just because there's some intention that involves some selfing doesn't mean we don't still give. We focus on what's wholesome there. I still gave the vase, but it was helpful to see that. It helps us purify our generosity. So beforehand, what's happening before we give the gift? When we give the gift, what's happening? What's our body feel like? What's the heart and mind feel like? What's happening in the midst of giving? And particularly when we're noticing the heart-mind, is there any sparkle of joy or delight or contentment, even just a little bit, We really want to be present for that. We want to notice if there's some pleasure in the giving. And this isn't because we're wanting to extract or milk something from the experience just for ourselves.
[19:43]
Rather, when we're present for wholesome pleasure, like the wholesome pleasure of dana, it begins to train the heart and mind where true happiness lies, that true happiness doesn't lie in just getting what we want and avoiding what we don't want. So on this note of practicing with generosity, I want to acknowledge that any deep study of generosity, any deep of generosity will reveal to us all of the ways that we're not generous. And that's not always that fun to see. It can be challenging to witness the ways that we're stingy or tight-fisted. And then it can be really easy to judge ourselves or be frustrated with ourselves or go to war with the stinginess. I'd just like to offer another option if you're really taking up
[20:50]
this practice of generosity, when you see these parts of the heart-mind, can you be generous with your own stinginess? So can you simultaneously cultivate generosity even when the opposite is present? So that doesn't mean doing whatever the stinginess tells us to do. It doesn't mean being hijacked by the stinginess. It does mean meeting it with loving awareness. with mindfulness. It means being patient with it, being compassionate with the stinginess. Maybe it means tenderly noticing the pain of the stinginess. And if we notice the pain of the stinginess, then we're noticing suffering in its cause, the first and second noble truth. That's exactly what the Buddha told us to notice. So if we can see that, we're right on track.
[21:52]
It's a really, really good thing to see. Worth celebrating, Eva. So to offer loving awareness, to offer mindful attention, these are acts of generosity. We can cultivate generosity even in the face of non-generosity. So along these same lines, I want to say a word about boundaries. So generosity It doesn't mean that we need to give beyond our means. I've seen a lot of spiritual practitioners over the years accidentally cause harm to themselves because they've given beyond their means and have overridden important boundaries. So the bodhisattva vow, it says, beings are numberless, I vow to sata. So we can hear that, and you hear these stories, you know, great saints and sages and the Buddha and the Jataka tales, and we could think that we're just supposed to fling ourselves to the tigers. But that doesn't always go so well, right?
[22:57]
So it's kind of a kill the ego approach. I've found works much better, as some teachers say, we love the ego to death. We don't kill the ego. And part of that process is being generous with our own need for boundaries, actually, to love this being in a conventional sense, to support this conventional being as it is. And so we can practice generosity and we can practice boundaries at the same time. So this is from the author and freedom worker, Jaya John. Your boundary need not be an angry electric fence that shocks those who touch it. It can be a consistent light around you that announces, I will be treated sacredly. For our generosity, it needs to be for the benefit of others and for ourselves.
[24:03]
So what about the perfection of generosity? It's said that each paramita is perfected when it's combined with the sixth paramita, wisdom. So dana, generosity, it's perfected when it's actualized with a deep understanding of emptiness. And when I say emptiness, if that is a term that's perplexing for you, You might just think, okay, empty, empty of what? Empty of separate self. It can serve as a little shorthand, or emptiness, if you find that term confusing. Empty of own being. So all objects, people, places, ideas, beliefs are empty. There's nothing fixed there. They're just changing phenomena. So...
[25:05]
David already spoke quite beautifully about emptiness and dana in the practice period class a couple days ago. But just to say briefly and remind you, in our Oriyuki chant, we have this phrase, may we with all beings realize the emptiness of the three wheels, giver, receiver, and gift. So giver, receiver, and gift are all, there's nothing fixed there, just these changing entities. There's no solid core or essence to that. I was thinking about this in relationship to my mom. So every Mother's Day, I try to write her a card, and I usually like to write all the things that I appreciate about her. And one of her primary virtues is her generosity. She's so generous with me. And so I usually write that.
[26:06]
And then it's not uncommon for her to respond something like, giving to you, my dear, is like my right hand giving to my left. So to me, that sounds a lot like the emptiness of the three wheels. Or just one body, the right hand giving to the left. So when we support all beings, Can it be like one body, the right hand giving to the left? There's a, in one of the Native American cultures, there's a tradition, actually I believe it's a ceremony, where the parents, they give really generously to the children. They give the kids food and gifts, and then they step back, and then they cry out, oh, I'm so hungry, I'm so thirsty. And then they allow the kids to give to them from this place of abundance. The right hand giving to the left, the left giving to the right, and back again.
[27:08]
And of course, the right hand isn't saying when it gives to the left, wow, I really hope somebody notices how generous I'm being right now. It's not like that. This points to emptiness of the three wheels. So just to bring these teachings on craving, and emptiness together. You might be wondering if the perfection of generosity has to do with emptiness, what does that have to do with the Four Noble Truths? How does that work? Well, if the paramitas point us towards emptiness and may, you're just talking about how we're going from the Second Noble Truth to the Third Noble Truth that has to do with craving and clinging, what's the relationship there? So craving and clinging are inextricably linked to selfing. It's actually craving and clinging that bring the self into being.
[28:12]
So there's an early Buddhist sutta that I think speaks to this quite nicely. And in it, Ananda is a brand new monk. And he's speaking with an elder monk. And this is actually, they're talking about this. They're having a similar conversation. And what the elder monk says is what causes, it's a condition for Ananda's first awakening experience, hearing this teaching. So the monk says, the elder monk, he says, it is by clinging Ananda that the notion I am occurs, not without clinging. It is by clinging Ananda that the notion I am occurs, not without clinging. So it's this grasping, this clinging, that brings the self into being. And then he continues, by clinging to what? By clinging to form, sensation, perception, and consciousness. The five advocates. And if you maybe happen to have chanted the Heart Sutra, you'll know form, feeling, perception, formation, and consciousness is all empty.
[29:24]
Empty of what? Empty of clinging. When we don't cling, we don't fabricate a sense of self. So that's where these come together. We often mistake these aspects of our experience for who we really are, when really they're just a river of change, a river of changing phenomena. So this is how these come together. All to say... When we practice generosity, we grow in this capacity for letting go. We grow in this capacity for releasing selfing. And we can cross over from the shore of delusion to the shore of awakening. So I'll end with a poetic rendition of Shantideva's verse. And I think this is such a lovely articulation of the Bodhisattva vow. And I think it beautifully expresses how we cross over.
[30:38]
And this particular rendition, the Dalai Lama chants this every morning when he wakes up, this particular translation. And maybe after hearing it, we will too. It goes like this. May I be a guard for those who need protection, a guide for those on the path, a boat, a raft, a bridge for those to cross the flood. May I be a lamp in the darkness, a resting place for the weary, and a healing medicine for all who are sick for as long as earth and sky endure, may I assist until all living beings are awakened. So may you too be a boat, a raft, and a bridge to help all beings cross the flood.
[31:45]
Thank you. We have some time for question and answers. Anyone? Thank you. You mentioned when we are giving to someone, we can stop and check in and say, oh, is there a feeling of joy? What if we start to cling to that feeling of joy and want that again? And on the flip side also, what if we're looking and we see, oh, I kind of regret that giving. Yeah, yeah.
[32:48]
So, so clinging. So, so if, if you look and you go, oh, there's some clinging here. then fantastic. You've seen clinging in your own heart. It's a really, really good thing to be able to see because when we don't see it, we're hijacked by it. It runs the show. So just to notice that that's present is a great thing. You don't have to fight the clinging. You don't have to get rid of it. Just notice what's there. And it's a natural habit of mine that when something's pleasant, we grab hold. And this is how Vedana works, how feeling tone works. If it's unpleasant, we push it away. So notice if it's there. And there are worse things to cling to than really wholesome states. It's a wholesome pleasure. And then your second piece, say again what the second piece of your question was? It's kind of the flip side to that where you're checking in with yourself after giving and there's a little bit of a kind of...
[33:48]
I kind of regret that or I wish I still had that. Yeah, yeah. Oh, interesting. So, yeah, kind of regret that, which could be all sorts of regrets, you know. One is, you know, I wish I still had that. But, you know, another could be, oh, you know, I gave this gift and I don't think it's serving the person. You know, it's like this doesn't seem like it's actually a good gift for them. It might be harming them in some way. That's the whole purpose of checking in before, during, and after, to learn from how we've acted, to learn was this a beneficial gift for those involved? Did this benefit or did it cause harm? And then we learn, oh, maybe I won't do it quite like that in the future. Thank you for your question. Hi, Mae.
[34:54]
Thank you for the talk. What kind of stuck out to me was when you said that you gave the vase to someone and like there was some part of it that was like kind of like for you too. I feel like I have something I want to give like just to the world and part of it is also for other people's benefit, but then I also feel like part of it I'm feeling like is for what I get out of it too. And I don't know if that's bad or like, can it be both? It can be both. It can be both. And actually that's often, it can be a really, like truly beautiful thing to find where, um, where our passion or something that really feeds us meets the world's need.
[35:55]
Frederick Buechner actually talks about true vocation as being where our deepest gladness meets the world's greatest need. So there can be a way where it feeds both. In my case, that 20% wasn't to deeply nourish and feed me. It was to try to look good. And that has a different valence to it, right? investigate within yourself, if you have this thing you want to give to the world, does it feel like an act of generosity to yourself? Or does it feel like it's feeding something unwholesome? Like something that we might not actually want to feed. Thanks, Risa. Hi, thank you very much for the talk.
[37:00]
My question regards clinging. And I wanted to know in your opinion, if there's something that an individual preciously clings onto, how do you suggest removing the attachment to something that they cling to and something that they might cling to very dearly about? So how might... that person let go of the clinging? Yes. Okay, yeah, yeah. I wasn't sure if you were saying, how do you get them to let go of the clinging? Which would be a different question. If this is the clinging, let's say, here's a little paper clip. Let's say, I'm really clinging to this paper clip. I really, really just can't live with this paper clip. So how do we practice with that? Practice with it like this. with our attention, with our care, with our tenderness, with our patience.
[38:03]
In fact, we can bring all of the paramitas to that clinging, not to get rid of it, but to cultivate generosity with, oh, you know, I can allow you to live here. This clinging, you can be here too, right? And we can go down each of the paramitas and let that practice with the clinging be our bodhisattva activity. And what we find is that we really value this idea of letting go, but we're not very good at doing it. And so I think of this practice as a little bit more like a letting-be practice. Ajahn Chah, the Thai forest master, he says, 80% of spiritual life is knowing we're clinging and not being able to let go. A lot of spiritual life. So a lot of it is just meeting the cling and knowing it as clinging, feeling it in the body. What's it feel like to cling?
[39:05]
Oh, wow, there's a lot of contraction here. This is actually, it's painful to cling. We want to see that really clearly. When we do, wisdom grows. And then the wisdom lets go of the cling. We don't have to get rid of the cling. We don't have to let go of the cling. Wisdom lets go of the cling. But we have to see the pain of the dukkha. We have to see the pain of the tanha. We have to see the pain of the clinging often over and over and over again for the mind-heart to let go on itself. So that's why we just hold it. Yeah. Thank you. I think it might be time to go to bed. Bedtime. Thank you for listening to this podcast offered by the San Francisco Zen Center.
[40:07]
Our Dharma talks are offered at no cost and this is made possible by the donations we receive. Your financial support helps us to continue to offer the Dharma. For more information, visit sfcc.org and click giving. May we fully enjoy the Domo.
[40:27]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_95.15