You are not logged in. You can log in or create an account to save favorites and join collections. more info

Kshanti Paramita: The Perfection of Patience

00:00
00:00
Audio loading...
AI Suggested Keywords: AI-generated, learn more
Description: 

Mei Elliott teaches that the cultivation of patience requires us to understand impatience more deeply in our own life and practice. Through this investigation, we grow our capacity for meeting experience with curiosity, wisdom, and compassion.

AI Summary: AI-generated, learn more

The talk presents kṣānti pāramitā (the perfection of patience) as maintaining a wholesome attitude amid difficulty, not suppressing impatience or passively accepting harm. It proposes recognizing impatience as craving or aversion combined with a sense of time, then meeting it through bodily awareness, compassion, and wisdom; patience can coexist with effort and skillful action.

Texts and works referenced
- Dōgen, Shōbōgenzō — The saying “Before the donkey has left, the horse has already arrived” is interpreted as patience arising even while impatience remains.
- Kobayashi Issa, haiku on a snail climbing Mount Fuji — “Oh, snail, climb Mount Fuji, but slowly, slowly” frames patient effort toward a vast undertaking.
- The Buddha’s teaching on hatred and love — The teaching that hatred ceases through love, not hatred, grounds love as a motive for wise action.
- Nelson Mandela, reflections on imprisonment — Mandela describes imprisonment as “an education in patience and perseverance,” illustrating hardship as training.
- Shunryū Suzuki, teaching on hell as training — The statement that “hell isn’t punishment, it’s training” supports treating difficulty as practice.
- Dalai Lama, response on the fastest way to enlightenment — The answer “patience” closes the talk by linking patience with the path to awakening.
- Nisargadatta Maharaj — The quotation about saving the world “from yourself” connects patience with avoiding harm to others.

AI Suggested Title: Patience as Wise Action

Is This AI Summary Helpful?
Your rating helps us improve AI summaries.
Transcript:

This podcast is offered by the San Francisco Zen Center on the web at www.sfcc.org. Our public programs are made possible by donations from people like you. Good evening. Let's start with a sound check. Is everybody hearing it? Yeah? Okay? Great. All right, I'd like to begin by thanking Abbott David. for inviting me to give the talk and to be Shuso for the practice period. My name is May. It's a pleasure to be here with you. I want to start the talk with a memory. So when I was in college, I spent about four months living in East Africa. And during that time, I spent a short period staying with the Hanza people. And for those who aren't familiar with the Hazza, they're one of the last remaining hunter-gatherer tribes. And they live off the land without agriculture, without livestock.

[01:05]

So they forage. They forage for tubers, for berries, for wild honey. And they're still out there using traditional bows and arrows to hunt game with just uncanny precision. Their society, it's entirely egalitarian, so there's no personal ownership. And spending time with them, it was really inspiring. It was really inspiring and so different from what I'm used to. So one very small detail of my stay there came to mind recently. So at some point, tobacco was introduced to the Hadza. And so they'd make little hand rolled cigarettes. But here's the thing. They don't have any matches or lighters. So every time they wanted a cigarette, they literally needed to take a stick, put it on the ground, and make a hand drill fire to create an ember in order to light their cigarette.

[02:19]

They literally needed to make fire from scratch in order to have a smoke. And I was thinking about that, and it occurred to me that if Americans needed to make fire from scratch every time they wanted a cigarette, they'd probably smoke a whole lot less. And my sense is just American culture at large in general there's not a lot of tolerance, there's not a lot of patience to wait for what we want. There's, you know, I want something and I want it now. This virtue of patience is not particularly well-developed, to say the least. So this is what I'll be speaking about tonight. I'll be speaking about this perfection of patience. Kashanti Paramita. We are in the midst of a six-week, 10-week practice period on the six perfections.

[03:22]

So Kashanti is one of them. That's the Sanskrit for patients. It's Kanti in Pali. So let's start with the basics. So by one definition, Patience is the capacity to accept or tolerate delay, trouble, or suffering without getting angry or upset. It's the ability to bear difficulty calmly, to have a balanced mind, to be steadfast even when things are hard. And I've noticed there's a common misunderstanding about patience, and it's that patience involves of gritting our teeth and bearing something difficult kind of like um like tightening against something or kind of bearing down and bracing against something difficult and that's not actually true patience so rather a more complete patience

[04:30]

involves meeting what's difficult while maintaining a wholesome attitude. So that's really the key of patience. We're maintaining a wholesome attitude in the face of difficulty. So how then do we cultivate patience? How do we cultivate patience in our life? So one might think that the path to patience involves getting rid of impatience. But I found that it's actually through impatience. We have to go through impatience to get to patients. It's not kind of going in the opposite direction of impatience. So we need to study impatience in order to get a sense of where we're going with this. And when I've taken a closer look at impatience to really understand what's happening, I've found that it's kind of... a combination of a couple different elements, kind of a composite. And the two elements, the two main elements that we see are one, craving and or aversion, wanting or not wanting.

[05:36]

And then two, a sense of time. A sense of time in relationship to that wanting and not wanting. So let's unpack that a bit, starting with the first one. craving, and or aversion. So impatience arises when wanting or not wanting are present. So when there's something that obstructs us from getting what we want, whether that thing is a cup of coffee or a bathroom break or a better job, whatever it is, if something obstructs us from getting what we want, typically impatience arises, right? We want rapid and unhindered access to whatever it is we desire with nothing in the way of that. And this is one of the reasons that we find ourselves so impatient when we encounter bad traffic or a long line. It's not the traffic or the line that are necessarily to blame, but they are obstructing forces between where we are now and what we want to get.

[06:40]

And then likewise, we can see how impatience comes into being from aversion also. So that's kind of how... We can see wanting leads to impatience, and then we can also see how not wanting, how aversion leads to impatience. So let's say there's something unpleasant that we don't want. Maybe it's maybe an illness or body pain, difficult mood, sadness, loss, anything like this. We typically want it to be over as fast as possible, right? There's this kind of, will this please go away already sort of sentiment. So in patients, it comes with this urge to rush through, this urge to get to a better moment. OK, so that's the first element, craving and or aversion. So now let's add that second element, a sense of time. And I want to say up front that this is not a Dharma talk on Dogen's uji. We're going to keep it a little more simple. And it's a subtle sense with impatience.

[07:47]

So maybe I can offer just some standard ways that the mind might present impatience. And you might hear the time-based element in them. So maybe there's the thought, I can't bear this headache any longer. Or... how much longer until this work meeting ends? Or when will that annoying person finally go away? So you can see how these examples have that element of desire and the element of time. I want X now, or I want to get rid of X now. So with impatience, it's a little bit like we're plagued by the gap between the way it is and how we want it to be. So maybe there's the thought, something like, oh, there's that construction noise again.

[08:49]

Please, will it stop already? It's just a little innocuous thought comes up. So impatient lives in that gap, that perceived time gap between how it actually is, which is noisy, and how we want it to be, which is quiet, right? So I mention all this because being able to understand how we construct impatience, how we bring impatience into being, it can really help us understand our way through impatience and to the other side of it. So maybe that means relaxing our craving and aversion, or maybe it means... settling into the present and meeting things as they are. So these are ways that we might move in the direction of patience. So when we have desire, we have this sense of time, then impatience tags along with us a little bit like a shadow.

[09:56]

And I like this analogy of a shadow for impatience because we don't typically notice We don't typically notice a shadow, right? It's typically following along, and we don't even know it's there. Likewise, with impatience, we don't tend to notice when it's present. So that's our first task with practicing with impatience. It's just recognition. Can we recognize impatience when it's present? So this is how do we practice with it? And when we start recognizing it, when we start seeing it in our life, it can be surprising to see how pervasive it is. And patients can come up while we're waiting for somebody to arrive. It can come up when we have a slow internet connection. Maybe we make a phone call and we're put on hold. The other day, I chose to burn my mouth on molten oatmeal rather than wait for it to cool down.

[11:02]

So this is this tug towards something we want. It's really strong. So we're just trying to meet it with clear recognition. And then as totally humbling as impatience can be, these small manifestations of impatience, they give us the opportunity to practice, right? These are kind of like And we could say minor league occasions to grow the capacity for patients for when we need it most. So if we want to be able to be with the most difficult things, we start small. If we want to lift a 100-pound weight, it really helps to start with a 5-pound weight. So we don't know when sickness or death will come for ourselves, for our loved ones. So we can train in this capacity to meet what's difficult and start small.

[12:04]

Start with a slow internet connection. That's a little bit easier. When I was in my mid-20s, I was presented with a 100-pound weight, so I had to learn the hard way. And some of you know this already. But in my early 20s, I woke up quite sick one morning. Really, really bad digestive pain. Couldn't eat. I could barely eat. Started seeing doctors. Didn't really know what was wrong. Days went by, weeks, months. And it just ended up being years of not knowing what was going on or why I was so sick. And during this time, I was very impatient. I really wanted to know what was wrong so I could treat it. And I was impatient about just wanting life to be normal again, to be pain-free, to be able to eat and drink as normal, to be able to go for a regular walk, to do yoga again or ride a bike.

[13:15]

There's a lot of yearning present. Fortunately, I already had a practice, had a meditation practice, and so I decided to go see a teacher. So I met with a teacher, explained this whole situation, how hard it was, all my angst. And he responded in a way that was a little unexpected for me. And it was also, it was unexpected and it was effective. And it was pretty much just a line, you know, just very brief teaching. He said, how would you be with this pain and this illness if you were to have it for the rest of your life? And I kind of, it struck me. Yeah, it wasn't, you know, it wasn't intended to bring forth fear or a sense of doom and gloom or anything like that.

[14:20]

It actually did the opposite, right? So by imagining this future where I didn't get better, it kind of pulled the rug out from under my craving for a better life or a better moment. So instead of that reach, it undercut my aversion and it undercut my sense of urgency. So I realized if I were to have this for the rest of my life, I would need to accept it. I would need to accept this is my life and this is okay. Just this moment as it is, it's like this, it's okay. And with that, yeah, that sense of clinging, that sense of urgency, it really subsided. And it was replaced with tolerance, with kashanti.

[15:23]

And then, of course, there were times when impatience would arise again. And when it did, I would do this practice where I would recognize impatience. And then I'd feel it in the body. I'd sense it in the body. So recognizing maybe the impatience manifests as restlessness or irritation or frustration or anger. So then recognizing that and then sensing what's it feel like in the body. Each emotion, it has a particular physical signature. So what's the physical signature of impatience for you? Maybe it's a tightness in the chest or a clenching in the jaw. Maybe it's a bracing in some area of the body. Can we get curious about that? Can we get to know that, like an ecologist in a new ecosystem, is bringing interest to this state.

[16:32]

If we do, something really beneficial can happen. we're able to pay attention in this way and really get to know what it feels like, we're much less likely to be fooled by it. We're much less likely to be hijacked by it. If we know what it feels like, we're much more likely to sense it right as it arises, and then we're not taken away by it in the same way. So this practice of knowing impatience and sensing it, That can be complete in and of itself. And if we can do that, chances are we're practicing patience with impatience. There's a line in the Shobo Genzo, before the donkey has left, the horse has already arrived. There's a lot of different ways that this can be interpreted, commonly, you know,

[17:34]

enlightenment and delusion. But tonight I'd like to think of it as patience and impatience. So the donkey is impatience and the horse is patience. So before the donkey has left, the horse has already arrived. In other words, before impatience has left, patience has already arrived. So we don't have to get rid of impatience in order to be cultivating patience. Right in the moment of impatience, we can meet that with patience. We can meet the impatience with a wholesome state, which is really great news because that means we don't need to get rid of anything. We don't need to tamper it with it. We just know it and sense it. And in doing that, we meet it with a wholesome state. That is patience right there. So we can recognize, we can feel. And if it's helpful, we can bring in a wisdom perspective.

[18:39]

We could bring in a compassion perspective. These are all means that can help open the heart, that can soften the heart. So I'll say a little bit more about the relationship between wisdom and compassion and this patience practice. So maybe we feel impatient. Something's happened. We feel impatient. we recognize it, we sense it in the body, and maybe we bring in some compassion. So what I've found is that that compassion, it softens impatience with its warmth. It kind of relaxes. So in the same way that a patient parent might meet an impatient child, we can meet our own our own inner struggle, our own impatience, with that same caring attention, with that same gentle, kind attention.

[19:41]

So we're bringing compassion to the child within, this vulnerable part that just wishes things were otherwise. It's not a crime to wish things were otherwise. It's often just a young part that needs attention, that needs care. And sometimes meeting impatience with compassion will reveal something underneath. So it's not uncommon that impatience is covering over another state. Maybe it's covering over loneliness or grief or sadness. So when we're able to look below the impatience, sometimes something else is revealed that's asking for loving attention. One time I was walking through the flower garden at Green Gulch. For those that don't know, Green Gulch is a sister temple to this one. So I was walking through the flower garden, and I ran into an old friend there and his maybe four-year-old daughter.

[20:51]

And this was a friend that I did monastic training with at Tassajara many years prior. It was kind of sweet to see him as a dad. So we stood there, we caught up for a little bit, and his daughter rummaged around in a garden bed, which held her attention for maybe two minutes, at which point she went to her dad and started tugging on his pant leg and started interrupting a little and then interrupting a little more and getting louder and louder. And it was actually... I'd make it sound like it was a slow escalation, but it was not a slow escalation. It pretty quickly bordered on tantrum zone. And what was so amazing to me is just how patient my friend was with his daughter. He was so calm, so gentle. He knelt down beside her and spoke in a really kind way, which was amazing.

[21:53]

Truly incredible, because at the same time, seeing that, I was reflecting on how amazing it is that parents don't eat their own young. So right as he said, it's fine, we can go. And right as they were leaving, I was just so impressed. I said, hey, I got to ask, how are you so patient? And he looked at me really surprised, and he said, you don't know what it's like in here. And I was like, huh, okay. So in this case, my friend didn't feel patient, but he enacted patients. He enacted patient activity. And that's really important. It's really important to know how to identify impatience in our system so we're not taken away by it, so we don't cause harm through it. We don't want to leak our impatience onto other people. So it's not that we never share impatience.

[22:59]

There's a time and a place to skillfully express frustration or anger. But if it's not that time, it's not that place, or you're not able to do it skillfully, it's probably a good idea not to leak it. Because ultimately, we want our patients to be in service to beings. We want to be in service to beings. We don't want our anger to cause harm to others. As Nisargadatta Maharaj said, if you want to save the world, you must first save the world from yourself. Okay, so maybe we recognize we're impatient, we feel it in the body, and then... And then maybe we bring wisdom to it. So that was an example of how we might bring compassion to meet our impatience. So what about bringing wisdom in? So patience as a paramita, it becomes perfected when it's combined with wisdom, when it's combined with the sixth paramita, prajna.

[24:10]

So wisdom, wisdom knows what to tolerate, when to tolerate it, and how to tolerate, how to be skillful. If we're in, say, an abusive relationship, if we just stayed in that relationship practicing patience, that might not be the wisest response. So patiently enduring abuse probably lacks wisdom. So wisdom brings in the knowledge of what to tolerate and when and how. So the perfection of patience, it's for the benefit of all beings, including you, right? You're part of that. So along these same lines, it could be easy for somebody to confuse patience with complacency or non-action.

[25:12]

So patience, it shouldn't be conflated with this, shouldn't be conflated with complacency or non-action. So for example, on our last one day sitting, I had a very busy mind. There was a lot of thinking, a lot of thinking, particularly in the morning. The morning was very thinky. But I was diligent about continuing to bring the mind back to the breath, back to the body, just continue to do it. So I wasn't frustrated with the mind. I wasn't striving to get a quiet mind. I was just content to continue bringing the mind back again and again. So I might have done it a thousand times that day. Would I have preferred a quiet mind? Yeah, I would have. But was I able to maintain a wholesome attitude in relationship to the mind I had?

[26:14]

Yeah. So I was patient with it. Patience was accessible that day. But just because I was patient doesn't mean that I was complacent with the thinking mind. Just because I was patient doesn't mean that I gave up efforting or I stopped trying. So tremendous effort can still be made from a mind that's patient, from a mind that's accepting. So when I was sick, I learned to meet my experience with acceptance, with patience, but that didn't mean that I stopped trying to find a treatment. I was really diligent about continuing to find something that could help my body. But I could do that from a place of patience or from a place of difficulty, of impatience. So David spoke about this quite beautifully in the practice period class a couple nights ago, talking about skillful action, when to engage in skillful action, when to be patient, when to tolerate.

[27:26]

And we spoke about what I'm about to mention a bit too, which is that some people when they hear about patience or acceptance, they wonder where the fuel to act comes from. It's kind of like if fear or anger aren't motivating us, how do we respond to injustice? What do we have to act from? There's no fuel. So sometimes fear and anger is all we have. And if that's the case, we do our best with it. But there's a much more powerful force of motivation in our life, and that's the force of love. Love is an incredibly powerful motivator. It motivates wise action, skillful action, and can make a lot of difference.

[28:30]

As the Buddha said, hatred never ceases by hatred. but by love alone is healed. This is an ancient and eternal law. So you don't need to think that patience will render you complacent. Maybe instead it will offer the resilience, the well-being in order to act in a much more powerful way. And amazing things can become possible. with patients. I sometimes think about Nelson Mandela as a model for this. For those that don't know, Nelson Mandela was the anti-apartheid activist who spent 27 years imprisoned and then eventually became the president of South Africa. So those 27 years in prison, they were in really harsh conditions, really isolated conditions.

[29:33]

And just to give you a sense of the isolation, I learned that he could only exchange one letter every six months, and he could only have one visitor once a year for a 30-minute period. So pretty dire circumstances. But despite these limitations, he was really steadfast. So I was reading some of his reflections about his time on Robben Island, and I was moved by how he related to this. He said he related to his imprisonment as, quote, an education in patience and perseverance. It sounds like the paramitas, right? The third and fourth paramita, patience, kashanti and virya, energy, right? He related to his imprisonment as an education in patience and perseverance.

[30:36]

So he related to it as a training. It was a training. This sounds like Suzuki Roshi when he said, hell isn't punishment, it's training. So can we relate to our own difficulty as a training? We all have this capacity for this heroic patience. there's a one-line poem that comes to mind. It's a Japanese haiku from the 19th century poet, Kobayashi Isa. It goes like this. Oh, snail, climb Mount Fuji, but slowly, slowly... Oh, snail, climb Mount Fuji, but slowly, slowly. So if we're in the work of, we're engaged in the work of saving all beings, that's a really big mountain to climb.

[31:46]

And we might feel a little bit too small for the task. But slowly, slowly, if we're impatient, it's going to be a really long climb. When we can meet our circumstances, our difficult circumstances, with this patient nobility, with this heroic patience, we're not the only ones who benefit. Our families benefit, our children benefit, our roommates, our coworkers. Everybody benefits from our peace. And while... kashanti paramita is a perfection, this practice doesn't require us to be perfect. If impatience is present, can we recognize it? Can we feel it in the body?

[32:48]

Can we meet it with compassion? Can we meet it with wisdom? And even if impatience is present, can we be patient with it? Can we cultivate patience with impatience? So I'll close with a very short quote by the Dalai Lama. It said that the Dalai Lama was once asked, what's the fastest way to enlighten it? And he gave a one-word answer, patience. So when you're faced with crossing the great flood of samsara, may you be supported by patience. And if that patience is mature, may you also enjoy the ride. Thank you. Thank you for listening to this podcast offered by the San Francisco Zen Center.

[33:51]

Our Dharma talks are offered at no cost and this is made possible by the donations we receive. Your financial support helps us to continue to offer the Dharma. For more information, visit sfcc.org and click giving. May we fully enjoy the Dharma.

[34:11]

@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_96.0