You are not logged in. You can log in or create an account to save favorites and join collections. more info
Love and Power: Responding to Fear
Shosan Victoria Austin, in this Halloween Dharma talk, focuses on the five cardinal fears named by the Buddha, as exemplified in modern song and story.
The talk presents fear as a response met not by suppression or control, but through support, inclusive awareness, and sustained relationships. It connects the Buddha’s five fears—death, illness, unusual states of mind, loss of livelihood or reputation, and public embarrassment—to the Sangaha Sutta’s four bonds of fellowship and Dōgen’s corresponding methods of guidance: giving, kind speech, beneficial action, and identity action.
Texts and works referenced
- “Bonds of Fellowship” (Sangaha Sutta; title and author not specified): Names generosity, kind words, beneficial help, and consistency as grounds for fellowship, which the talk presents as practical support for meeting fear.
- “The Bodhisattvas’ Four Methods of Guidance,” Dōgen: Recasts the four grounds of fellowship as giving, kind speech, beneficial action, and identity action; these practices are presented as ways to sustain connection and respond to fear.
- The Heart Sutra (author not specified): Its teaching on form and emptiness supports an inclusive view in which experience is impermanent and without fixed self, loosening the conditions that sustain fear.
- “Stage Fright,” Melissa Kirsch, The New York Times (article): Uses childhood Halloween fears to illustrate how perceived threats persist and why the unknown is not necessarily dangerous.
- ** Coraline, Neil Gaiman (book; film adaptation also referenced): Serves as an example of fear associated with altered states and unsettling relationships.
- ** Goosebumps, R. L. Stine (children’s horror series): Appears in the New York Times article’s account of childhood fears and their later reinterpretation.**
Speakers and figures referred to
- The Buddha: Identified as the source of the teaching on five cardinal fears and the four grounds of fellowship.
- Dōgen: Connects the Sangaha Sutta’s principles to the four methods of bodhisattva guidance.
- Moggallāna: Appears in the account underlying the Sejiki ceremony, in which offerings and spiritual support address hungry spirits.
- Shunryū Suzuki and Mel Weitsman: Acknowledged as figures in the teaching lineage referenced in the talk.
AI Suggested Title: Meeting Fear Through Fellowship
This podcast is offered by the San Francisco Zen Center on the web at www.sfcc.org. Our public programs are made possible by donations from people like you. Good morning. Welcome to Beginner's Mind Temple. To introduce myself, my name is Shoshan Victoria Austin. I'm a priest here at San Francisco Zen Center. and completely indebted to the people upon whose shoulders I stand and whose hands I hold. So I'd like to thank some of the people who are now gone, of course, Suzuki Roshi, and my teacher, Sojin, Mel Weitzman. And then also I'd like to thank the abbot and the tonto So Abbot David and Tonto Tim, thank you for inviting me to speak on this Halloween day.
[01:07]
So I'd like to start with an important song that I learned in childhood. And I think everybody might know a different version of the song, but parents and grandparents and people who were young Please feel free to join me. This is a New York variation. Ready? Never laugh when a hearse goes by because you may be the next to die. They wrap you up in a bloody sheet and bury you under six feet deep. All goes well for a couple of weeks, but then your coffin begins to leak. The worms crawl out, the worms crawl up, sorry. The worms crawl in, the worms crawl out. The worms play pinochle on your snout. Your stomach turns a slimy green and pus comes out like shaving cream.
[02:15]
You lap it up with a piece of bread and that's what you eat when you are dead. So I think this is important because, you know, sorry. I really do because, you know, children rehearse these things, these issues that everyone's scared of in a very straightforward fashion and one that invites us to join. So how many of you know Neil Gaiman's book and the movie Coraline? You know it? Isn't it one of the scariest, for people who know it, one of the scariest movies and books ever? So in Coraline, there's an intrepid girl named Coraline. I'm going to tell you because you might not have heard this.
[03:16]
This is an important fear-based story. So she's a very, very brave kid. And she loves exploring. She loves finding out new things, the house and the grounds. And one day it rains and she feels stuck. And while wandering around the house, she opens a little mysterious door that she's never seen before. And she is transported into a realm that's the exact mirror opposite of her own house and her own mom. And the parents in the house and the animals in the house all have button eyes. It's really scary, actually. So they all act like automatons. And you can tell that they don't really love her.
[04:17]
Okay, so that's a... I won't tell you the end because I don't want to spoil it for you. But again, this is... Just like the song is... explores our fear of death and decomposition. This book and this movie explore the idea of unusual states of mind and unusual states of relationship that are scary for children and for grown-ups. And today, Halloween is the perfect day to study these scary things. And I don't know if you know, but Halloween used to be a serious holiday, a really serious holiday. It was a religious holiday, All Hallows' Eve, in which a multitude of hungry ghosts and spirits would come out, and we would face our darkest fears before inviting in the saints.
[05:28]
And, of course, this was not my home tradition, but there are people here for whom it was their home tradition. And so please correct me if I'm wrong, okay? And I want to say that last night we had an absolutely spot-on, terrific Sejiki ceremony that does much the same thing. So Sejiki means it's a ceremony in which, let's see, it was started when I believe it was Modgaliana, had a dream. Come on in, Valerie. Valerie. There's chairs on the other side in the courtyard, and you can bring one in? Yeah. Okay. So, had a vision of his mom, who had died, being trapped in the flames of hell. and realized that her spirit couldn't dissolve, her karma couldn't be over, because she, even after death, her yearnings, her desires, her difficulties were so strong that they had taken on a life of their own beyond her life.
[06:45]
And so that's the story behind this ceremony. And in the ceremony, you can see we're still set up for it. The altar is back there by the five Buddha family, And in the ceremony, Abbot David came and called the hungry spirit with mudras and mantras to come and be satisfied. And actually, there's a food offering with a leaf where you kind of mush it up. And it's usually stuff like ding-dongs and ho-ho's and M&M's for the hungry ghosts. So a Buddha is covered because... the hungry ghosts would be scared by the conventional forms of respect. And then after that, we call on the Buddhas and ancestors as supportive spirits. And supportive spirits, you know, fear, the basic raw emotion of fear cries out for support.
[07:51]
So we call on the different names of Buddha, and the awakening beings for support in the ceremony to help turn this backwards realm, this topsy-turvy realm that we've set up, into a sacred space where all beings, desires unfulfilled and undernourished, can be held and satisfied. And then... We call on the families of Buddha, and these banners that are all around are some of the major Buddhas that can support people in fear. So they're Buddhas of courage, they're Buddhas of acceptance, and so on. And then, the hungry ghosts are fed on a physical level, And they have the support of the Buddhas and ancestors throughout time.
[08:55]
And the everlasting aspect of the various Buddhas who can help them right now. And the next thing that we do is ordain them. So I don't know if you know that in Dogen, Dogen is the founder of our school in Japan. He went over to China to learn about Zen and he brought it back to Japan. and it grew in Japan in various ways and finally came to us in the United States. But, yeah, okay, I'm sorry, I don't want to really go to Dogen right now, so I'll backtrack a little bit. But, oh, yeah, no, maybe I will. So, because Tim's in the room, so I want to talk about this robe Tim is in charge of our sewing. And you see people around wearing the big robe, which is called the okesa, and the small robe, which is called the rakusu, which just means small robe.
[09:58]
And this robe, we chant about it every morning. Great robe of liberation, field far beyond form and emptiness. Wearing the Tathagata, the one who comes thus, is teaching, saving or freeing all beings. So we wear the teaching. We wear the teaching. We wrap ourselves in the teaching. And it transforms our experience from a field of suffering to a field of blessing. So this is a support that's present in this room and can be present around our bodies and minds. And there are people who received the precepts just last week who received these vows and received the rope and received this kind of support in their life. It's very helpful to have the support of people who have been on the path, people who exemplify the path, friends who can hold your hand while you try to be on the path, witnesses who can help.
[11:05]
It's really, really helpful. But what Dogen said was even if someone puts on the robe as a joke, it predicts their future awakening. So even if the hungry ghosts are only ordained kind of involuntarily, it protects them throughout the future. Moggalyayana could protect his mom by doing this ceremony on her behalf. And we can protect Our states of fear, come on in. Have a seat anywhere. Do you want a cushion or a chair? You're good? Because there's plenty of extra cushions around. As I said, fear requires support, just like anger requires boundaries.
[12:07]
Anger requires boundaries and respect and, you know, you have to feed that angry spirit with a sense of being safely and almost luxuriously held. Fear requires support, a support that feels safe. And so all of those Buddha's ancestors' names and food and people chanting and weird sounds and costumes and stuff that we do in the ceremony that we had last night, give the hungry spirits the idea that they can be fed and that they can turn towards the path, maybe not now, but in the future. So this weekend, Dave and I are going to be teaching about love and power, responding to fear. So that's why I'm talking about fear and more about that later. I want to talk about some of the traditional ways that we meet fear in our practice and some of the kind of power-ups that I think we need in the 21st century and particularly going into elections week.
[13:26]
So elections week, many people are afraid on every side of the political spectrum of what might happen if the other side wins. And the other side, you can read in the media, has often been portrayed as demons or threatening figures that will ruin everything. Doesn't matter who you are or what you believe, the other side has been amped up to be bad and scary. And so there's a lot of fear going around. What happens if this? What happens if that? And so, and it's not just the election. There's wars. There's methane. There's increasing temperatures and there's data centers and and all sorts of things that people are concerned about today.
[14:27]
So what kind of supports do we need today? And I want to point out that fear was often handled in the early teaching by kind of rehearsing it the way that kids rehearse it in the hearse song or in Coraline, in movies like Coraline, where you go into a cemetery and one of the big fears is death, And you sit there and look at someone who's just died, someone who's in the process of being buried, someone who has been buried for a while or has been dead for a while. You look at that and you sit there with acceptance. And it's the vows and the practices that support you to do that. And that is a wonderful practice. And I want to say that I think we need stronger medicine right now to feel safe. that it can't just be monastics living in kind of super-supported environments like Tassajara, where thousands, hundreds of thousands, and maybe even millions of people are supporting the practice to go on for these three months in a monastery like Tassajara.
[15:43]
There's donors through the ages. There's everyone who's received zazen instruction or practiced or everything. It's so supported. But people often in this day and age feel alone, even though the internet, AI, connect us more than ever. It doesn't guarantee that there'll be a connection that satisfies us in the heart. As you were saying this morning in the weaving ceremony, what do we hold in our heart and how do we nourish that part of ourselves to make that dimension of our life make sense? where we need it the most. So I want to point out a totally different part of Dogen's teachings that helps in times like this. It's more on the order of what we say in the Heart Sutra.
[16:51]
that when we understand that form is emptiness, emptiness is form, that which is form is emptiness, that which is emptiness form, when we understand that everything is a flashing in the midst of a great light, and that it has a beginning, a middle, and an end, and a change is possible, and none of it is identified with a fixed self, and all of it is limited, when we understand that, no hindrances can bother us. And without the hindrances, no fears can exist. If we're not obstructed, if our experience or perception is inclusive, fear can't arise in the same way because we're supported by everything. And so I want to point out a completely different set of teachings besides gravestone graveyard meditations and the like that can support our feeling of safety in the midst of fear.
[17:56]
So one of those is called Sangaha Sutta, the bonds of fellowship. So to establish fellowship in the body, you might want to stop listening to me for a second and just adjust yourself on your buttock bones, reestablish the comfort of your legs and of your back so that you can hear me And I can speak to you without you feeling, without you being, without doubt coming up due to physical pain. So we keep ourselves refreshed to be able to concentrate. And hearing is actually a creative process that's different from listening. So that's why we do that. When we involve the whole body and mind in reflective hearing, then also... Fear can't dominate us in the same way. And that's where the sutras like the Sangaha Sutta come in. So I'll just read it to you. It's actually a basis of some teaching that was rewritten many, many years later by Dogen Zenji.
[19:07]
So this is the sutra. There are four grounds for the bonds of fellowship. Which four? Generosity, kind words, beneficial help, consistency. These are the four grounds for the bonds of fellowship. Fellowship meaning togetherness, intimacy that allows us to feel safely held. So the poem is generosity, kind words, beneficial help, consistency in the face of events aligned with what's appropriate in each case in each case these bonds of fellowship are in the world like the linchpin in a moving cart if these bonds of fellowship were lacking a mother would not receive the honor and respect owed by her child nor would a father receive what the child owes him
[20:17]
But because the wise show regard for these bonds of fellowship, they achieve greatness and are praised. So simple. Giving, kind words and actions, and a mind that continues in the face of ups and downs. And we've been studying patience, and if we want to understand how to manifest patience in ways that aren't about the feeling of forbearance, but about the activity of forbearance. This is where we'll go. We'll learn how to speak about our issues or problems in friendly or neutral ways. We'll learn how to act kindly to ourselves and others when faced with them. And we'll learn how to act in accord with other human beings and with beings in every realm.
[21:20]
And that gives us the physical, perceptual, intellectual and emotional support to have the physical, organic or energetic, intellectual and spiritual oomph to persist. and forgive in the face of fear and pain. So the five fears, we've already covered some of them through examples. The five fears that the Buddha taught are death, harsang, illness, similar, unusual states of mind, Coraline, loss of Livelihood or reputation, I think we can all relate to that. Modern times are teaching that.
[22:24]
And fear of embarrassing oneself in public. Am I speaking the Dorm, or am I talking trash, you know? Is this helpful or is it not helpful? What do people think of me, you know? those could run somebody who's in front of the room. Fortunately, that's not the practice, to allow oneself to be run by that. And it doesn't get cured by dominating that feeling or turning it into something else. It gets cured by having a more inclusive spirit that kind of obviates that fear. It just is not that relevant to what's actually going on here, which is that we're bringing up the Dharma. We're bringing up a path that can actually help us with our suffering anywhere it arises, whether it arises from our basic attractions and aversions or whether it's further down the line of thinking or acting.
[23:36]
We're all helping each other just by being here on a Saturday morning. bringing up the Dharma, bringing up the topic. So there's so much more I could say about this. You know, there's a lot in this, in these sutras, but I want to read a few things and just comment on them if I could. So I just read you the... The five fears and the idea that intimacy can help with those. And I want to fast forward almost a thousand years to Dogen Zenji to just read how he put it, that same material from the Sangaha Sutta. And so you can see what happened as Buddhism made its way through India.
[24:44]
China to Japan. So this is written in the 1200s and it's called the Bodhisattvas or Awakening Beings for Methods of Guidance. I'll just read like one sentence from each paragraph of this. So Dogen begins. And this translation is by Kaz Tanahashi and Lou Richmond. Lou Richmond was a student of Suzuki Roshi's, and he received Dharma transmission from Ed Satasan, who was abbot here until a few years ago. And Lou is an amazing musician and a kind person who writes about work practice about aging as spiritual practices. So I highly recommend his writings.
[25:45]
If you want to read something in the modern age, that's really good and helpful. So the bodhisattvas' four methods of guidance are giving, kind speech, beneficial action, and identity action. Sounds pretty similar, doesn't it? Giving, kind speech, beneficial action, identity action. Giving means non-greed. Non-greed means not coveting, not currying favor. Even if you govern four continents, always convey the correct teaching with non-greed. So that's giving. Kind speech. Oh, well, the end of that section. is mind is beyond measure. Gifts are beyond measure. Moreover, in giving, mind transforms gift.
[26:49]
Gift transforms mind. So giving means that you establish friendliness with someone, which means you can tolerate more from them. And so giving and patience are strongly related. Kind speech means that when you see sentient beings, you arouse a mind of compassion and offer words of loving care. It is contrary to cruel or violent speech. In the secular world, there is the custom of asking after someone's health. In Buddhism, there is the phrase, please treasure yourself, and the respectful address to seniors, might I ask how you are? And then he says, it is kind speech to speak to sentient beings as you would to a baby. And I think what he means by speaking to a baby is, you know how when they put that newborn into your hands, this thing happens?
[27:50]
Right? And something comes up, it's like, I'll do anything, baby. I'll do... What do you need? I'll do it. And then pretty soon that goes by the wayside because the baby goes, wah, wah, and you kind of go, ah, no, what do they need? Oh, no, oh, no, I'm killing them, you know. At least maybe that doesn't happen for you, but I'm not a mother, so, you know, especially when I'm holding somebody else's baby, there's always that fear that I'm ruining the baby, right? And then quickly that gives way to being a little more accurate about what I perceive. But for that flash of a second, there's that doubt and fear, right? Oh no, here's this absolutely pure being and the way I'm holding them. And then immediately my hand's gentle and my hand can hear the baby's being, right? As soon as I drop the fear, right?
[29:01]
So I think that's what Dogen means. So he also says, be willing to practice it for this entire life. Do not give up world after world, life after life. And then he says, he ends this paragraph by saying, kind speech arises from kind mind, kind mind from the seat of compassion. Ponder the fact that kind speech is not just praising others' merit. It has the power to turn the destiny of the nation. Okay? It has the power to turn the destiny of the nation. And then third, beneficial action. Skillfully to benefit all classes of sentient beings. That is...
[30:01]
to care about their distant and close future and to help them with skillful means. So it means benefit self and others alike, benefit friend and enemy equally. If you have this mind, even beneficial action for the sake of grasses, trees, wind and water is spontaneous and unremitting. Dogen says elsewhere, like a hammer striking emptiness. This being so, make a wholehearted effort to help. And then the fourth one, identity action, is a little weirder to try to understand, a little more, like what? Identity action? What's that? So I just want to point out something from recent history. Chuck, who's sitting in the back row there, could you raise your hand, Chuck? Chuck was in The Diggers, and The Diggers was a group of people that, against local law, distributed free food and resources to people just because they were human.
[31:12]
That's identity action. That's an example of identity action from our history. Also, Ellen making basics kits for kids in schools is an example of identity action. OK? There are so many people I could mention who are doing identity action, but I don't want to out anybody who isn't already in the public eye, so I won't. Know that you can look at the person next to you and they have done something that is an example of identity action. What is it? What can you see in them that goes with your deepest wish?
[32:16]
So it means non-difference. It's non-difference from self, non-difference from others. It means right... The action part of it means the form, the deportment, the dignity, the manner. We cause ourselves to be in identity with others and them to be in identity with us. The relationship of self and others varies limitlessly with circumstances, so that's why we have to look diligently and really look for this. You know, dance. Dancing with someone, that's an example of identity action. So then it says, each of these four methods of guidance includes all four. So they're all holographic. So that's how these practices that the Buddha taught played out a thousand years later and how they can play out now.
[33:27]
And we're the agents of how it plays out now. So the priest ordained people, I think, are responsible to be visible in the uniform with the deportment that's been taught so it can manifest in this generation, so it can continue to another generation. And lay people, I think, have the responsibility for... your life, your talents, your relationships, your jobs, your connections, but also to make sure that priest practice doesn't go awry and become narrow and dour. Okay? So priests can help make it so that in practice it's not like, oh, anything goes. Just because I'm doing anything, it is practice. No, it's a gateway to practice. lay people can help priests understand that, you know, looking this way is not the only way to practice and that we're all necessary for the path, all of us together and all of us differently with a united heart and a united mind.
[34:48]
And doing these four actions giving kind words, beneficial help, and tranquil, constant mind in every circumstance, are how our kind of gut equipment, our equipment for patience and forbearance arises in the midst of fear. After all, fear is negativity projected into the future, something that will be beyond our control. beyond our power to take care of our law. But these bigger actions that we can do for and with each other make our experience big enough to hold whatever might come and to hold it in friendly ways. So I want to end with a story from today's paper. This was in the morning section of
[35:53]
the New York Times this morning, and I just want to read this story, okay, a little bit of the story now that we're on scary kid stuff. It's okay if I do? So it's called Stage Fright, and it's by Melissa Kirsch. My landlord's spooky season sidewalk tableau this year features three skeletons carrying an open casket. inside of which is yet another skeleton as well as a disembodied hand. One morning last week, I emerged from the building to see two women with infants in strollers parked out front. It's not unusual around Halloween to see families taking pictures of the spectacle, but I found it amusing that these people had stopped to show it to their babies. What would these tiny humans make of a surprisingly lifelike, rotten-toothed crone beckoning them from the hedge. Would they recognize Halloween's creepy cast of characters as frightening?
[36:55]
Perhaps they were too young to even register what they were seeing. Perhaps the world in their eyes was still a series of shapes, light and color, dot, dot, dot. The things that spook us as children leave their mark. We grow into adults who must disentangle real threats from perceived ones. and often discover that a present-day fear took root when we were too young to know better. Dot, dot, dot. In a recent Times article, the writer Alessandra Shada record that as a child, she lived next door to the Goosebumps author R.L. Stine. She read his horror stories for kids. She convinced herself that Stine's house was haunted. Twenty years later, Shada met Stein, who told her about his career and how he came to inhabit the home from whose chimney she once was certain she saw ghosts floating. She learned that Stein and his wife, who met when they were editing magazines at Scholastic in the 1960s, had lived there on a quiet cul-de-sac in Sag Harbor on the eastern end of Long Island for a quarter century.
[38:08]
The source of her childhood anxiety turned out to be, as she put it, a friendly octogenarian who goes by Bob. Our childhood fears resist rationalization. We can turn on the light and see that the boogeyman is just a pile of clothes, but we sleep with one eye open nonetheless. As adults, we have the tools to distinguish between real and imagined peril. but we don't always use them. The scary album is replaced by the amorphous worry, dot, dot, dot. We picture the worst case scenario. We still see monsters where there's just dirty laundry. No matter how old we get, we still need to remind ourselves that what is unknown or mysterious to us isn't necessarily dangerous. Halloween is a laboratory for experimenting with this.
[39:09]
All around us, bedsheet ghosts haunt the neighbor's oak tree. Spiders as big as hatchbacks climb up the sides of tenements. And children, the one most likely to shrink from this pageant of rites, walk through it delightedly, meeting witches and vampires and learning to distinguish costume from reality. Thank you very much. May your candies be all individually wrapped. And may you be happy and well, joyous, free from suffering, the causes of suffering, and free from fear. And thank you very much for your attention. And those who are coming this afternoon, Later you can announce perhaps something about what we're doing. And people who are in the practice period, thank you for inspiring this talk.
[40:18]
So, let's. Thank you for listening to this podcast offered by the San Francisco Zen Center. Our Dharma talks are offered at no cost and this is made possible by the donations we receive. Your financial support helps us to continue to offer the Dharma. For more information, visit sfcc.org and click giving. May we fully enjoy the Dharma.
[40:46]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_98.56