You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more. more info

Unraveling Identity Through Zen Practice

(AI Title)
00:00
00:00
Audio loading...
Serial: 
SF-08877

AI Suggested Keywords:

Summary: 

Talk by Chimyo Atkinson at City Center on 2023-05-25

AI Summary: 

The talk concerns navigating vulnerability and identity through Zen practice, illustrated by personal experiences in Japan and reflections on the teachings of Kezan Zenji. The narrative intertwines concepts of practicing Zen as a communal engagement, the weight of personal self-conceptions, and the metaphorical journey likened to a monk's literal mountain climb, examining fear, identity, and the idea of no-self.

  • Kezan Zenji: Recognized as the founder of Sojiji and considered the maternal counterpart to Dogen in Soto Zen, underscoring an essential historical context for Soto practitioners.
  • Poetry by Kezan Zenji: Reflects on finding stillness and emptiness, symbolizing the heart of Zazen practice.
  • Bodhidharma's Story: Illustrates the idea of becoming light and moving beyond constructed identities, emphasizing letting go of ego and self-conceptions in Zen practice.

AI Suggested Title: Unraveling Identity Through Zen Practice

Is This AI Summary Helpful?
Your vote will be used to help train our summarizer!
Transcript: 

This is watching. Well.

[04:06]

I'm going to start off with a little poem that is attributed to Kezan Zenji. And I'm not going to go into the ins and outs of Kezan Zenji, but he is the founder of the second Daihansan big temple in Japan. There's a Heiji in Sojiji. He is the founder of Sojiji. And he is considered, Will Dogen is considered the father of Soto Zen. Kezan is the mother. And I invite you to look that up if you don't know too much about it. This weekend, they're going to be celebrating the 700th anniversary of Kezan. in Los Angeles at that big celebration that they're having. So maybe appropriate.

[08:26]

This is one of my favorite little Zen poems. And sometimes I feel like I know what it means and sometimes I don't. Abandoning myself to breathing out and letting breathing in naturally still me. All that is left is an empty cushion under the vast sky, the weight of a flame. Abandoning myself to breathing out and letting breathing in naturally still me, all that is left is an empty cushion under the vast sky, the weight of a flame. In a memory I have, and remember, a memory is not real. It's a carbon copy of Xerox of something that happened in the past that's no longer with me.

[09:31]

But in memory, on a narrow road winding up the mountain above a monastery in Japan, I'm walking. I talk a lot about my experiences in Japan because it's one of my hundred foot pole depths, you know, that where, you know, there's no nothing underneath me. No knowing, no expectation. And I'm just out there. And For me, maybe not for everyone, that breaks something that needs to be broken so that I can let go a little bit. So on this narrow road above the monastery, there are or were on one side of the road, a shiitake farm in the woods.

[10:42]

And further on into those woods, you can hear, if not see, a stream that flows down the mountain. On the other side of the road is the mountain. Gray and green with vegetation. Oftentimes just wet for no reason. Kind of... The track was really easily walkable up to a point, but it could be dark and gloomy, smelled green. Sometimes you could hear wild boar in the distance grunting or doing whatever they do. Very often we monks would walk up this mountain trail for exercise and a little quiet or a little, well, it's always quiet, but a little alone time.

[12:00]

The track was made for these little white trucks of the farmers who were working those shiitake farms. and fields. So it wasn't very wide. I don't know if you've ever seen all those little K trucks that they have in Japan. They look like giant hunkers. So I'm walking there, and at a certain point on this track, the scene changes. The trees start to get lower and lower as the path goes higher. And the stone, as I recall it, changes quite a bit. It changes from this gray sort of muddy wall to a lighter color that in the sunlight seems bright yellow.

[13:07]

And the track It seems to get narrower and that changes too. The stone looks soft and crumbling. And at some point it goes above the trees. You get above the trees and the water is down below. I'm not sure where it came out of the mountain or how it comes through that, through what crevice. But You can hear the water far below. And on one side, there's the yellow wall, yellow crumbly wall. On the other side, there's nothing but air. I always stopped, you know, well before I got to this place and my walks. But one day,

[14:10]

I saw ahead of me one of my brother monks going ahead and going up further up the mountain onto the cliff, what looks like a cliff face. He's walking pretty briskly. He's a tall man. And I could see the... I want to say cords, but the ties of his... Sam away, flapping in the wind as he's walking. And I said, I can go there. He went, I can go. And I started to follow him. Now, I have a severe fear of heights. But that doesn't mean... that I don't want to see. What's the view from that cliff face?

[15:17]

I'd rather see a picture. But, you know, something in me just wanted to try. So I kept walking and the road gets narrower. And the funny thing is that you could see tire tracks on this trail. where these little trucks have been rolling up there and there's like this much space, you know, just inches between the set of tracks and that steep drop. So it's not that big, you know, it's not that big a road. And I got there and I went maybe far enough to really clear the trees. And you could see where, on the side of the drop where the rock was crumbling. It looked so precarious and so dangerous, even though it probably wasn't as dangerous as it was making me feel it was.

[16:26]

And I got there and I got to the middle of this cliff looking out and Suddenly there was nothing. You know, the road's still there, you know, but it felt like nothing. And I just kind of backed up against the wall. And I could see out over the trees. I could hear the water rushing below. And nothing. And the sun beaming onto my face as I kind of clutched. That yellow rock. And I saw the clouds, you know, passing overhead. It wasn't so high that we were actually in the clouds. But I could see them overhead. And I looked up. And there was a lot of talk, you know, in the monastery.

[17:32]

They called us nsui clouds. Difting clouds. And that's what, you know, I thought it was supposed to be, but I wasn't that day. When I got back down to the monastery, I actually made it back down. I won't see. I'd still be hanging on to that cliff, I guess. I wouldn't be here. I later wrote a letter to my teacher. And in that letter, I wrote the phrase, I think, I'm too heavy for this life. Because as I walk down that mountain, the fear and the feeling of unworthiness, feeling like a coward, of not feeling capable of continuing

[18:35]

And then that feeling, you know, not just the feeling of not continuing on that road, but just not. You know, total lack of confidence. Who was I to be there? Why was I wasting my time? It was so heavy. And I can remember that view, scary as it was. And I'm glad I saw it, scary as it was. And I felt that sun on my face, on my body, out there, and I felt the wind whipping through my clothes. But that day I couldn't go, but so far.

[19:43]

What I'm trying to say there, I think, you know, practice is never a solitary thing. Even if I sit in Zazen alone in my apartment or in the mountain, I'm not cutting myself off from the world and the conditions. Zazen is an effort to do the opposite, to drop the boundaries and the shields and be vulnerable. It's letting all the connections connect, including connections to falling rocks, wind and rain, and balancing on the edge of existence, standing on the precipice and feeling that wind and the weather and feeling maybe a little lack of confidence.

[21:07]

And feeling also, you know, in watching my brother walk his path, feeling that encouragement, that inspiration from others, small inspirations sometimes. Don't be scared. Come on. It's really not about being strong or being courageous. You can be all those things. It's more about standing upright with your clothes flapping in the wind and being sure-footed on that path. Not carrying anything.

[22:09]

Not carrying fear or courage. Not carrying anything. you know, who you're supposed to be or whatever. Your body and mind dropping away like a cloud. That takes a long time to cultivate in this practice. I'm still scared to hide. I know I have to look. I know I have to go up there and look. You know? I may not get all the way down the path at one particular time, but maybe a little farther next time. Another, what did I put it?

[23:10]

Another experience that I had on the mountain, I wrote about much later. Again, old memory, not real, but still in. Now, I hope I'm not going to take up too much time reading this, but let's see. On another day, doing that same kind of walk that I just described on the mountain. I peered down at the gravel at my feet on a narrow road above the monastery. A gigantic blue worm writhed there. Its dimensions more like a snake than a worm. They have these big, giant worms that are just really, they're amazing. They're really long, you know. Gigantic blue worm, dimensions more like a snake than a worm. The creature was just going about its business in the rain-soaked forest near the shiitake farm.

[24:19]

I was just going about mine, I thought, when its strangeness stopped me in my tracks, like nothing I'd ever imagined could exist. Terrified and fascinated, I was in wonderland. I was finally here on Earth with all its possibilities. When I came to myself, stepped over the worm, and continued my afternoon stroll back to the temple, I kept looking down for more monsters. I encountered no others that day, but I knew that amazing being was not the only one. I knew there were other strange creatures behind the trees that had not yet been a part of my consciousness before I made it to Japan. As magnificent as a worm can be, I'm not trying to compare myself to this worm. However, I am also accustomed to being perceived as strange as the strange one, regardless of whether or not I am in my natural environment.

[25:25]

I'm a descendant of African peoples living in America. I'm a Buddhist. I'm a woman. All of these statements have some meaning for whoever. What they've meant for me in the past has been hardship. joy, pride, self-defense, falling into mental, physical, financial, social abysses, and climbing out again and again. It has meant crossing the road. Work. It has meant crossing the road, minding my own business, and finding myself the object of someone's disgust, fear, fascination, ignorance, apathy, violence, or just plain disregarded. Up on the mountain above the monastery, I experienced freedom. I belonged to no race, no nation, no planet. My existence prior to the monastery had been defined as shy, black, female, poor.

[26:29]

On the mountain, I sang to the top of my lungs and listened to that voice echo over the rice fields and temple roofs like a bird's call, and I was nobody's anything. And I was just like that worm. And I felt, you know, I'd never seen the worm again. I've seen pictures of it because I've tried to explain to people what I'm talking about, a blue worm. You know, I never saw that worm again. I never saw another one. But just the understanding that the two of us were on that mountain together, you know, strange as we both are. And that we were that mountain. Think about the forest and all the things that you can't even see that make that forest. Crazy looking worms. I don't have any idea what the function of this worm is.

[27:30]

Maybe it's just there for the beauty of it. Or maybe it's holding the whole mountain together. The worm and its other buddy worms and all the other animals and people. and plants that make the world, holding it all together. And I was one of those beings that day with that great worm. We talk a lot about identity, you know, and I'm talking, you know, this month about no self and how harsh that is to some people's ears, no self. We spend a lot of time trying to figure out who we are and try to tell other people who we are and trying to avoid other people's interpretations or rather correct other people's interpretations of who we are. Sometimes succumbing to ideas of who we are as women, as men, as Americans.

[28:41]

Gay or straight, you know, what does that mean? Does it mean a thing? Because regardless, this is. This is. Deal with it. Love it. Use it, please. Receive. I kind of received a little lesson. Well, not a lesson, but again, an inspiration from that worm on that mountain. That this is strange as it is. And in that brief realization, because of course, ego, starts again.

[29:45]

There was a freedom that I had never felt before. A freedom that meant that, you know, I wasn't shy. You know, I talk so much, people don't believe me, but, you know, I can easily go sit in a corner and hide from you all, all day. Ego makes you die. I was a kid. My grandmother used to tell me stories. She'd be looking for me all over the house. And I'd be under the table. Quietly playing. Because there are people out there. There are, you know, times when I still come to this wall that says I'm not supposed to be here.

[30:53]

Well, who else is supposed to be here? I remember standing in this room years and years ago when I was first ordained, early part of my ordained life, and Daigaku Rume, Reverend Rume, was here. And I kept standing in the back with my robes on. And one day he just pulled me into the first row of the rear bond. I said, I don't think I'm supposed to be up here. Who else is supposed to be here? And it was just like, oh, that was that Dogen, you know, the first lap. You know, one of them, one of many for me, you know. Who else is supposed to be here but us? But you. It's great weight.

[31:54]

That we carry. That keeps us from floating like clouds. In this practice. In this life. You know. Carrying everybody's expectations. About who we are. And what we're supposed to be doing. AND WHETHER THIS PRACTICE IS WORKING AND THIS AND THAT. OF COURSE I'M DIVERGING FROM MY SCRIPT. I TRY TO STAY ON IT, BUT THAT'S OKAY. MY FORM, FUNCTION, MIND. Life is changing all the time, just as those of every other being around me. We are constantly becoming because of each other.

[32:56]

If there weren't so much resistance, this might just be fun. I don't know where I was going with that. I'm glad y'all can't see my notes. A gentle flame has some weight in the world. There, I looked it up. It's like 0.3 something. I don't do numbers. But it actually has some weight in the world. It burns and it warms for however long it exists. It flickers and floats and dances. It lights the bit of the world that it inhabits. And then it's gone. But as it does all that. It sheds the fuel and the energy from which it manifests.

[33:58]

This body sits on the cushion. Moves through the world. I hope. I hope I'm shedding its delusion. At least a little. Emptying the fear and the identities. Sitting, you know, in Zazen is not all. It's not all. What am I trying to say? It's action and inaction, kind of. happening without happening. We think that this practice is not working because it's hard to see the effects in the world.

[35:11]

Sometimes we feel And if practice is real, then everything we do, everything we do in the samsara is practice. And as small as the flame is, or as large as the flame is, it has some effect in the world. It affects everything around what I call I. So it's my most important, it's most important for me to make the greatest effort I can in this practice. Shoakogamara says, Satan is good for nothing.

[36:15]

And he's right. It's good for nothing. But in that nothing, it's not like it's... You know, we vanish. We disappear. We simply... We simply fold into... I don't know how to say this. I wrote something silly here. But we simply... come into the big self. And so that flame warms everything. It spreads out to all of the beings to whom we are connected and in this life with. Not even just this life, but lives beyond. And that helps to

[37:16]

Hold, you know, us here. The way the sky holds the cloud, you know, the clouds are part of the sky. And the cloud holds the sky and the sky holds the cloud and the mountain holds the worm and it's holding me and the water and the shiitake and even those little trucks rolling up and down. We are all. part of that mountain. We are that mountain. That's the mountain. That's just it. We're going up on it again. The weight of a flame. We are as light as we can be at any given time.

[38:20]

And the weight is not really, you know, real. The weight is here. One of the favorite images that I have is of Bodhidharma floating on a twig. Remember the story? He answered the emperor's question and the emperor was a little upset when he said, you know, when he answered, who is this in front before me? And Bodhidharma says, don't know. And then he said, just took off and went off to Yangtze, where the case says, he goes, I can't remember. Lots of things right now. But I do remember the image of Bodhidharma, this great big old man with big eyes, you know, floating on the river on a twig.

[39:26]

And I think, can I be that light? Can I just keep going? Flapping in the wind. Why not? So I keep trying. And that's what this is all about. Okay. Am I doing okay with this? I was at 825. I think I'm doing okay. So I think I just want to close with when I go. close the talking part, with this poem again. Abandoning myself to breathing out and letting breathing in naturally still me. All that is left is an empty cushion under the vast sky, the weight of a flame.

[40:35]

So that's kind of what I have to say tonight. And I hope I haven't been talking too much. So if any of you have any questions or any comments, please feel free. Or anyone, if there's anyone online. have lots of these stories about Japan.

[41:46]

You'd think I'd lived in Japan all my life for at least 20 years. I think I might have spent a little under a year in Japan all together and all the times that I went. And I'm not saying that anybody needs to go to Japan. But these were You know, I lived a very provincial life in New York City. I was like, you know, the most... I had a lot of experience. But there were never really experiences that really challenged me except maybe going to school, you know, going to college, you know. But mostly, you know, my life has been very... pedestrian, go to work, go to school. So this opportunity that happened to me almost by accident, almost unplanned, and took me out of all the things that I thought I should do or needed to do or was good to do.

[43:12]

through me for a good, hard loop. I'm always grateful for these experiences. And I think, I hope everyone here, you know, finds lots of holes to jump off of. You know, it will... IT COULD SAVE YOUR LIFE. I MUST HAVE SAID SOMETHING. I DIDN'T OFFEND EVERYBODY. NEW SPEAKERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TALK. ACTUALLY AS YOU WERE DESCRIBING HOW MUCH YOU GOT OUT OF ONE YEAR OF YOUR JAPANESE TRAVELS. I WAS THINKING OF THE PHRASE IT SHARPENS YOUR PERCEPTION WHEN YOUR BACK'S AGAINST THE WALL.

[44:18]

HAVE YOU HEARD THIS ONE? THINGS LIKE THAT. AND THEN YOU DESCRIBED YOUR PROVINCIAL LIFE AND I THOUGHT NOW IS THERE A WAY THAT WE CAN HAVE OUR PERCEPTIONS BE SHARPENED WITHOUT GOING TO JAPAN AND HOW IS IT CAN YOU ADDRESS IT FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF WHEN YOUR BACK IS AGAINST THE WALL FIRST AND THEN OR TO PICK IT APART ANY WAY YOU LIKE, HOW DO WE KEEP THAT SHARP PERCEPTION THAT MAKES EVERY DAY MEMORABLE AND A STORY OR TWO OUT OF EVERY WEEK? I DON'T THINK IT WORKS THAT WAY, REALLY. WITH YOUR BACK AGAINST THE WALL, YOU GET THAT PRETTY MUCH ALL THE TIME. When your bat's against the wall, that means you're in some kind of suffering mode.

[45:19]

And we don't need to go there. What we need is something that is going to make me see clearly what's going on. And nothing makes you see more clearly than you jump off that pole and the ground's coming at you. And there is nothing you can do about it except be right there. So I don't think we need to find that back against the wall suffering. We have that often enough. But what we need to do is make choices onto a path and commit to it. You know, commit to the free fall. You know, not all the time. That's just not possible for everybody. Japan just happened to be mine. I don't know what yours would look like, you know.

[46:23]

It has to do with the conditions of your life. But you just have to be willing. willing when that opening is there and you see it to just commit and go wherever that takes you. And know that, and also trust and know that it may not take you where you thought you were going, but it's going to be somewhere and you can survive that. You know, you don't have to bend in it. Turn that into suffering. You turn it into, you know, a great opportunity to open your eyes and see something for real. You know, see something, you know, get out of the habit mind and see something you've never seen before that you can't interpret. Your blue worm. You got to find your blue worm, you know. And you got to meet it and say, I can accept this.

[47:32]

I can. live in this. I can make this a part of my world, you know, and tear down some walls so that it can come in. You know, that's the real, you know, scary thing. That's when your back's against the wall, that means you made a wall back there that you slammed yourself against and, you know, you just cut yourself off from something. That's what I hear when you say back against the wall. It might not be the way you meant it, but that's why I hear that these days. So I don't know what your leap is going to be. You don't know either. No, I don't think I do. No, but you'll see it. Yeah. And it'll happen. There you go. Thank you.

[48:34]

Thank you. Time for a short question. Thank you for your talk. I have an image from an earlier talk of standing upright when the wind is blowing, which feels... I guess has sort of stability and weight to it. And then image from tonight of the flame and the empty cushion and movement. And in some ways those images feel different, but I'm wondering if there's something you would say about them that is actually the same or similar. What was the last thing? The image from tonight of more movement and the flame. AND THE LIGHTNESS OF THE FLAME AND THE EMPTY CUSHION.

[49:36]

AND I'M WONDERING IF YOU WOULD SAY THERE'S SOMETHING, ALTHOUGH THOSE FEEL LIKE DIFFERENT IMAGES, I'M WONDERING IF YOU WOULD FEEL LIKE THERE'S SOMETHING, SOME ELEMENT OF THEM THAT CONNECTS THEM OR IS SIMILAR. WELL, MY MIXING OF METAPHORS HERE. And the way I'm kind of seeing it, I guess, is that flame, that energy, you know, is both physical and ephemeral. It's both here and... In my mind, when you see a flame, you're seeing something passing through, burning away, you know.

[50:38]

And it moves and blazes up and it, you know, fizzles out. And that's kind of... it's kind of this life really you know how to explain I'm going to write something else it's I was trying to say something to the effect that even in its sort of passing away state, fizzling state, burning away state. It's affecting the world. It's lighting the world.

[51:41]

It's warming the world. And this body, you know, this body-mind, you know, that drops away, you know, same thing, you know, the energy from this practice, the energy from this effort, Affects the world and that it provides light, warmth, support to all beings. Maybe it was a bad metaphor. I don't know. Maybe I should have just said that in the first place. Forget the talk. I wrote this.

[52:43]

I was writing on this. I kept having to nap during the week for some reason. And so I ended up writing some things in the night. And when it gets nighttime, I get... I kind of get funny. My expressions sometimes get a little woo-woo. Thank you. Thank you for asking. I'm sorry. I made it confusing. I think that brings us to our time. Shall we close with the chant? Sure. Before I go, can we just have a little appreciation and joy for the passing of our newly minted cultural ancestor?

[55:04]

Can you talk about a life of hundreds of souls? Yeah, I'm glad you don't expect this because I'm not yet. All right. Thank you.

[57:47]

@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_96.0