You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more. more info
Creating Refuge in Belonging
Exploring the possiblity of transformation and creating a Sangha of Belonging by giving ourselves over to each other.
03/02/2022, Horin Nancy Petring, dharma talk at City Center.
The talk explores the theme of taking refuge within the Zen practice, focusing on the creation and nurturing of a community or Sangha. It discusses the significance of belonging and freedom, illustrated through Zen practice and reflections from personal experiences within various communities. The talk references Joy Harjo's poems and highlights the importance of multicultural communication agreements aimed at fostering inclusivity within the San Francisco Zen Center. The teachings of Eihei Dogen on the Bodhisattva's methods of guidance underscore the conversation, emphasizing generosity and the act of giving in community building.
Referenced Works:
-
"Conflict Resolution for Holy Beings" by Joy Harjo: This collection of poems is cited for its exploration of human complexity and interconnectedness, resonating with the talk's theme of universal belonging.
-
Eihei Dogen's Teachings on the Bodhisattva Four Methods of Guidance: Dogen's emphasis on giving as a core practice of the Bodhisattva way is aligned with the discussion of community and the agreements for multicultural interactions proposed at the Zen Center.
-
Visions Inc.'s Agreements for Multicultural Interactions: These principles are foundational to creating an inclusive and diverse Sangha, as discussed in the talk, and are positioned as necessary tools for effective community engagement.
AI Suggested Title: Zen Refuge: Building Belonging Together
This podcast is offered by the San Francisco Zen Center on the web at www.sfcc.org. Our public programs are made possible by donations from people like you. Good evening, everyone. Can you hear me okay? Yeah, great. There's a lot of background noise this evening on Page Street, it seems. Cars and dogs and some kind of a chorus or something happening across the street. Anyway, you may hear some background noise. Yes, as Brian said, my name is Nancy Petran, and my pronouns are she, her. I'm speaking with you from City Center, which is on the unceded land of the Ramatush Ohlone people.
[01:00]
Okay. So as we arrive, coming into a supported, comfortable, upright posture or attitude, noticing as we arrive, the reverberations of what was happening as we turned on our videos and settled in the energy of the day. What a feeling of aliveness is here for you. taking a few long breaths, noticing the shifting of awareness.
[02:17]
It's been a difficult week, bearing witness to so much suffering in Ukraine, people's lives. So many people's lives just shattered from one day to the next. And here we have come together, together in Sangha, for those using closed caption, that's S-A-N-G-H-A. or community of practitioners, community of those who have committed to living an awake life, an awakening life, committed to exploring
[03:35]
fullness and what that means, our human fullness and what that means. So if you feel comfortable, I would ask us who are willing to turn on our videos for a moment and that each of us can just take a moment to scroll through and take each other in, in Sangha. And of course, if you don't feel comfortable turning on your camera, please do not. of us shining our corner of the world.
[04:55]
Thank you, everyone. And please turn off your videos if you feel more comfortable that way. I really want this to be a comfortable space of belonging. So as many of you know, since late January, we have been participating in an eight week practice period, turning the theme of refuge with senior Dharma teachers, Christina Lenhair and Paul Haller. You know, what it means to engage in the practice, the practice of taking refuge, the practice of creating refuge. And what is it that we return to?
[06:05]
What is it that is true? What is it that is unchanging? And this part of the teaching, which is really kind of got me in taking refuge, that we create refuge for ourselves and for others. In taking refuge, we create refuge for ourselves and for others. This week, I was in conversation with one of the residents here at Zen Center. I don't know her very well at all. And we were talking a little bit about sangha community.
[07:10]
And I told her, I shared with her that I grew up in Catholic community, actually here in San Francisco. And she asked me, how did that feel? What did it feel like? And her question, the way that she phrased it kind of caught me off guard. So when I paused to actually see how that felt, I think I went to a very old place of belonging, a very old place of of community. And it was a wonderful feeling that I connected with Catholic San Francisco in the 1970s. It was a wonderful way to grow up in community.
[08:15]
And that came up as I checked in for, you know, a moment. And then what came pretty soon on its tail was, you know, as I became an adult, that what I was tuning into the teachings that I was hearing at mass and that it began to feel very narrow to me. it began to feel very defined, you know, what was allowed, what wasn't allowed. And as I grew in that awareness, I became quite uncomfortable. And my friend Tova shared this collection of poems with me, and I'd like to share this with you from Joy Harjo.
[09:18]
poet laureate, the first Native American poet laureate of the United States. And in her collection of poems called Conflict Resolution for Holy Beings. Conflict Resolution for Holy Beings. She says, each human is a complex, contradictory story. Some stories within us have been unfolding for years. Others are trembling with new life as they peak above the horizon. Each is a zigzag of emotional design and ancestral architecture. All the stories in the Earth's mind are connected.
[10:22]
Each human is a complex, contradictory story. Some stories within us have been unfolding for years. Others are trembling with fresh life as they peak above the horizon. Each is a zigzag of emotional design and ancestral architecture. All the stories in the Earth's mind are connected. So this description of each human sounds very familiar to me. It sounds to me like the one who takes the cushion who sits on the cushion and takes my place, sitting down in Zazen with the fullness, with the fullness.
[11:31]
And I say sitting down in Zazen, it could be lying down in Zazen. It could be whatever posture it is in which you engage Zazen with the fullness of our humanity. the complexity, the contradictory, and the unfolding, the folding and the unfolding of very familiar stories. And then that, the little fresh life, this to me, the fresh life, our human experience. Each moment new. So as we sit down in Zazen, And all of this settles in the little sense, the little taste perhaps of refuge, of a sense of belonging or a sense of freedom, belonging to the earth's mind, a belonging to our true nature.
[12:38]
So, Back to my question, taking refuge in Sangha. And how do we create Sangha? How do we create this culture, a culture of belonging, a culture where each of our bodies, as my young body did, feels safe, feels a sense of belonging, looks around and sees myself, that each of us see ourselves reflected in the Sangha and know that there's a place for us here in this Sangha. So taking refuge in Sangha, how do we create this sense, this sense of belonging in Sangha? How do we develop a sensitivity
[13:44]
to each other's experiences. So in 2018, after a lot of many, many years, I would say actually, and Paul Heller was reminding us of this the other day in a conversation of working here at Zen Center, working on diversity, working to create this culture of belonging, of inclusivity. And in 2018, this effort brought an initiative where San Francisco Zen Center committed to a set of agreements.
[14:45]
They're called agreements for multicultural interactions. And these agreements are agreements that are posted throughout the temple. They're a part of our reconciliation process. So the request of people gathering to meet and to take up the issues at Sun Center or residence meeting, any kind of meeting where we're coming together is to actually engage, to practice with these agreements, to hold these agreements together. So I think it's important to actually look at the history of where the agreements originated and to give credit there.
[15:51]
So these agreements came from a nonprofit called Visions Inc. And Visions Inc. was founded by three black women who grew up in legalized segregation and a white Jewish man. who grew up in the civil rights movement. And they created this nonprofit and brought together many agents of change in the field of education, psychology, law, religion. And with this question of how do we include people who have historically been excluded from predominantly white and mostly male institutions? How do we create within the organizations as they are now room for everyone to thrive, to thrive and to stay, to belong?
[17:09]
The request for us to take this up here at Zen Center from leadership at the time, for me, I understand it as a reminder, a reminder that as we gather, each time we gather together, that there's actually the potential to be changed, to be changed by each other, to be seen, to be heard, to be reflected in one another. And I'm going to actually, let me see if I can do this, Brian. This is, I hope, that is the PDF. Did that go to everyone? Let's see. Let's see if it goes down.
[18:15]
Yes. So that is the PDF of our agreements for multicultural interactions. And I guess the other thing that I have in turning these again, and I want to go through this, but I wanted you to have the PDF because engaging in this way in whatever meeting we're in, I think of as a lifetime practice. They keep changing for me. Different ones come forward. So I'd like to just read through these with you. You can just listen if you would like. You now have the PDF. for later. So you can put that aside for now. But as we take these up, perhaps there's one that is alive for you.
[19:22]
Again, this is a lot of practice. This is a lifetime of practice. And the reason that I wanted to bring this forward tonight is because I feel as though this really is here and available for us and it is already a part of this sangha and the work that we're doing together. So you can listen as I go through them. Try it on. So here we are and this is that we're entering into a gathering where ideas are going to be shared and voices are going to be shared. We're creating a safe place for everyone to participate. So try it on. Be willing to try on new ideas or ways of doing things that might not be what you prefer or are familiar with.
[20:27]
Practice self-focus. Attend to and speak about your own experiences and responses. Do not speak for a whole group or express assumptions about the experience of others. Understand the difference between intent and impact. Try to understand and acknowledge impact, denying the impact of something said by focusing on intent is often more destructive than the initial interaction. Practice both and. When speaking, substitute and for but. This practice acknowledges and honors multiple realities.
[21:32]
Refrain from blaming or shaming self and others. Practice giving skillful feedback. Move up, move back. Encourage full participation by all present. Take note of who is speaking and who is not. This is up to each of us to track. If you tend to speak often, consider moving back. If you do not speak often, consider being courageous and stepping forward. Practice mindful listening. Try to avoid planning what you'll say as you listen to others. Be willing to be surprised to learn something new. Listen with your whole mind.
[22:38]
Self. Listen with your whole self. What is being said under the words? Sensing into each other. Confidentiality. Take home learnings, but don't identify anyone other than yourself now or later. If you want to follow up with anyone regarding something they said in a session, ask first and respect their wishes. Write to pass. You can say, I pass, if you do not wish to speak. Understanding the difference between intent and impact.
[23:45]
I think for me, this has been very alive. I see very much where immediately I want to defend my intention and learning to step back, to feel that come up, but to step back and be undefended. You know, what is it to be? undefended and say sorry and actually take in what someone has shared and really feel what impact I have had on someone, usually very naively, ignorantly, but such a growing place, you know. I think that most of us think of ourselves as very good people, you know, and what is it to really open ourselves to hear the impact that we have on others without defending ourselves as the good person, our good intentions.
[24:53]
So as I was just reading through those, that was really a lie for me just this evening. And in terms of this creating a culture of belonging, the agreement that has really been alive for me is stepping up, stepping back. And I've been noticing lately how, you know, I think that this is, you know, making room for all voices, as Joy Harjo says, of the Earth's mind, for all voices to have space to step up and step back, I notice I have an internal clock that if things go on in silence beyond that comfort of being in silence together, I feel that I need to fill it with my voice.
[26:00]
I need to intervene, interject myself somehow in this situation. So can I step back? and stay there for a while. And also, all of these agreements are about actually staying in the conversation, staying in the conversation. As a community of practitioners, I believe it's so important for us to stay in the conversation and perhaps notice when we're stepping back and disengaging, you know, stemming back and disengaging and removing ourselves from an uncomfortable conversation, you know.
[27:05]
So each of these practices of us to give over in a way. Each of these agreements asks generosity of us to allow ourselves to be changed and to change. and be changed. So that awareness, that awareness that we cultivate in our zazen of giving over, you know, giving over to a place of freedom.
[28:10]
So, I'd like to end with the teachings of our 13th century ancestor, Ehe Dogen, and his teachings on the Bodhisattva Four Methods of Guidance. in the four methods of guidance. Hey, Dogen. So there are four methods that he says for living the Bodhisattva way of life. And the first is giving. And then actually the next three are also based on giving. So what I hear Dogen telling me is that it's all about giving. It's about giving over. Paul and Christina introduced
[29:16]
the paramitas as the next place of exploration and taking and creating refuge. So when I heard giving, you know, I always think of Eh Hei Dogen because so many things in that fascicle are so beautiful, so much of Dogen's writing about giving. some of it makes sense of it to me and that all of a sudden I'm completely lost as happens with Dogen. There are some things that he said back in the 1200s that come to me often from this writing. So I offer it to you And again, you can see what resonates for you, what pops out for you.
[30:24]
When you leave the way to the way, you attain the way. At the time of attaining the way, the way is always left to the way. When treasure is left, Just as treasure, treasure becomes giving. You give yourself to yourself and others to others. Buddha said, when a person who practices giving goes to an assembly, people take notice. You should know, this is Dogen, you should know that the mind of such a person communicates subtly with others. Therefore, give even a phrase or verse of the truth.
[31:36]
It will be a wholesome seed for this and other lifetimes. And later he says, this is all because the giver is willing. So I think Dogen is speaking about our agreements for multicultural communications back in the 1200s. As did the Buddha, when a person who practices giving goes to an assembly, people take notice. And Dogen, you should know that the mind of such a person communicates suddenly with others. Therefore, give even a phrase or verse of the truth. It will be a wholesome seed for this and other lifetimes.
[32:38]
stories in the earth's mind are connected. Thank you for listening to this podcast offered by the San Francisco Zen Center. Our Dharma talks are offered at no cost and this is made possible by the donations we receive. Your financial support helps us to continue to offer the Dharma. For more information visit sfcc.org and click giving. May we fully enjoy the Dharma.
[33:22]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_97.86