You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more.
Hokyo Zammai Class
AI Suggested Keywords:
The talk delves into the intricate relationship between the Rinzai and Soto Zen lineages, highlighting how they are viewed as congruent, rather than opposing, through the discussion of the Ketchumyaku document. It then transitions into an exploration of the eight levels of consciousness as conceptualized within the Yogācāra school of Mahayana Buddhism, detailing how these levels connect with the five ranks and their culmination in the realization of the four wisdoms. The purification of consciousness and the potential for personal transformation are emphasized, setting the stage for further analysis of Zen teachings and practices.
-
Platform Sutra (Wang Mulam version translation): Discusses enlightenment where the first and fifth ranks are said to correspond, serving as a reference for understanding unity in Zen thought.
-
Hakuin Ekaku's Commentary: Examines the five ranks and their purpose in realizing the Four Wisdoms, underpinning the talk’s examination of Zen practices.
-
Vimalakīrti Sutra and Mūlamadhyamakakārikā: Underpinning theories in understanding consciousness, though not referenced explicitly, their philosophies are integral to the concepts discussed.
-
Transformation at the Base by Thich Nhat Hanh: A recommended text interlinking consciousness with karma, emphasizing the potential for transformation, and suggested as essential reading for understanding Zen teachings.
-
Daidyō Shōgongyuron: Referenced during the talk, connects the inversion of eight consciousnesses with the production of four wisdoms, critical for comprehending consciousness transformation in Zen.
-
Shingon/Vajrayana School (Two Mandalas): Explored as sources for understanding the eight consciousnesses and their role in Buddhist teachings, showing the interconnection of Zen with broader Buddhist esotericism.
These references provide a structured foundation for understanding Zen consciousness theory, spiritual practices, and their transformative applications.
AI Suggested Title: Harmonizing Zen Consciousness Pathways
Side: A
Speaker: Sojun Mel Weitsman
Location: ZMC
Possible Title: Hokyo Zammai
Additional text: Class #9
@AI-Vision_v003
Good morning. When we do that chant, we tend to hold on to some of the syllables. It's a little too long, but I'm not going to go into that. Good morning. Can you understand me? three, two, three, four, five, seven, five, six, seven, eight, nine,
[01:11]
You mentioned last time You mentioned last time that the keshvyaku is part of the transmission document, and it's also part of lay ordination, I think. And you were also talking about the Northern versus Southern and Soto versus Rinzai. Well, in the lay ordination keshvyaku that I have, It shows the goat, and it also shows the ring guy on the other side, and there's a little thing at the bottom that says it shows that the two are actually one. Is that related to that? Stop.
[02:43]
uh... [...] His teacher went to China together. But also Lin Shi. Yeah, I spit, and I went... That did it.
[03:51]
But who knows if it's going to continue. So he says the Rinzai line and the Soto line are two lines. Two. Soto and Rinzai are... two, I can't remember, two line, I write this down all the time, mutually congruent with each other. Because the Rinzai, all the schools in China were just the ancestors. But anyway, so on one side of the Ketchumyaku is Rinzai lineage and the other side is Soto lineage. Yeah, so it's not one versus the other. So what I've handed out here in this table of 5843, whatever that means, it means nothing here, is what you see on the blackboard, what I wrote out last time.
[05:15]
And you can see that on the left are the five positions called ranks. And next to that are the eight levels of consciousness, which correspond to these ranks. And next to that are the four wisdoms, which correspond to both of those. And on the right are the bodies, the dharmakaya, zamurakaya, and the manakaya, which correspond to the other three. So all of these are corresponding to each other. So you see how the various ways of looking at reality fit together? What? It looks like unity of pain being the highest rank, yet if I go down the consciousness it goes up, down the tie, down the aggregate.
[06:36]
Well, the first rank and the fifth rank correspond to each other. In enlightenment, those two correspond to each other. They become the same thing. The Platform Sutra has a, the one I was, the Wang Mulam version translation has a footnote about that. I didn't bring that with me. So, if we look at Hakuen's commentary, where it begins, I can't tell you what page this is,
[07:45]
But it's not where it actually begins. It's where he talks about, where he's talking about the main principle. Shoju Rojin has said... We read this once, but I'm going to read it over because this is what introduces us to this, what we're doing. Soju Rojin, his teacher, has said, in order to provide a means whereby students might directly experience the four wisdoms, right, wisdoms, four wisdoms, that seems to be the whole purpose of, the main purpose of the five ranks, is to realize the Four Wisdoms, even though it doesn't say so in the Hokyo Zamai.
[08:49]
He said, this is the reason for all of this. He says, in order to provide a means whereby students might directly experience the Four Wisdoms, the ancestors, in their compassion and with their skill in devising expedience, which means all the teachings, all the teachings are simply expedients, first instituted the five ranks. You get that? What are the so-called four wisdoms? They are the great perfect mirror wisdom, the universal nature wisdom, the marvelous observing wisdom, and the perfecting of action wisdom. And then he talks about, which is very important, but I want to skip that. We go back to that. I want to go back to, go on to, see that down there? And I'm talking about Hakon's talk. In Hakuen's talk, he says, do you know why?
[10:05]
I'm skipping all the stuff that went before that. Do you see where he says, do you know why? Pure gall that has gone through a thousand smeltings does not become ore a second time, which means that this is the essence, right? All the rest of the stuff has gone through the smelting and only the essence remains. My only fear is that a little gain will suffice you. How priceless is the more it gains through the step-by-step practice of the five ranks of the apparent and real. Okay. By this practice, you not only attain the four wisdoms, but you personally prove that the three bodies also are whole and lost within your own body. Okay. Have you not read in the Daidyo Shogongyuron, I'm not sure what that is, but it doesn't matter. When the eight consciousnesses are inverted, the four wisdoms are produced. So he's introducing the eight consciousnesses.
[11:08]
So the four wisdoms are tied up with the eight levels of consciousness, which you have in front of you in the sheet. When the four lesbians are bound together, I don't know what bound together means, but the three bodies are perfected, Dhammakaya, Sambhogakaya, and Humayakaya. Therefore, Sokhedashi, who is Daikan Eno, composed this verse. Your own nature is provided with the three bodies. When its boldness is manifested, the four wisdoms are attained. He also said, the pure Dharakaya is your nature, the perfect Sambhogakaya is your wisdom, and the million Dharakayas are your activities. So it's not just something written on paper. Okay, but all I can hear is myself now. That's better. Anyway, you know better than I do what you hear.
[12:11]
So, in order to explicate this, I want to talk about the eight levels of consciousness, which is a big study, big study, that we're going to talk about in a short amount of time. But I will give you the gist of the eight levels of consciousness. Now, if we look at this, where it says consciousness, it says, H. Alara Storehouse, in your piece of paper. It says eight, alaya consciousness. And then it says seventh, manas, ego. Sixth, manavijjana, individuating. And fifth, one to five, senses. So, according to Mahayana Buddhists understand, the Mahayana Buddhists
[13:14]
especially the Yogacara school, developed this model of consciousness. It's a model of consciousness. All the schools of Buddhism, Buddhism has always been very interested in what the levels and meaning of consciousness are. Because consciousness is so important in understanding Buddhadharma. So the development of a model, this model, this is the latest model, the many models of consciousness in Buddhism, but this is the latest model, which came out around the second century or something like that, talks about Not just six levels of consciousness, which is usual. In psychology, you have eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose, sight consciousness, sound consciousness, taste consciousness, touch consciousness, and mouth consciousness.
[14:32]
nose consciousness, smelling consciousness, and mind consciousness. So starting from the bottom, we have the first five sense consciousnesses, which the senses are perceptors. They perceive, but they don't think, as we know. They simply are the doorways of consciousness. the doorways to mind consciousness. And mind consciousness takes the information and assimilates it. So the first five consciousnesses are simply doorways. And in order for consciousness to arise, there has to be an object, an organ, and a subject, the subject being consciousness, subjective.
[15:34]
So we say object is objective, consciousness is subjective, and in between is the connector. The connector is the eye, the ear, the nose, and so forth. And mind consciousness is called mano-vijnana. That's the sixth, what's here is the sixth consciousness, just above one to five. I'm starting from the bottom, going up. Mind consciousness, mano-vijnana, discriminates, is a discriminating consciousness which discriminates between the sensual input. In other words, I see. I hear. This is what Manu Vijnana, the function of Manu Vijnana is to discriminate between the various, the five consciousnesses in order to adapt to the so-called objective world and recognizes what is objective.
[16:48]
That's how things get made up. and labels things? Well, I think so, yeah. Labels and recognizes. So, discriminates. So, consciousness is not necessarily discriminative, but there are levels of consciousness which discriminate. So, discrimination takes one whole thing and divides it into parts. So, mind consciousness discriminates one thing into various parts and says, this is you and this is you. But you and you are really one thing.
[17:51]
But mind consciousness discriminates the various forms and compares one to another. And we create, through mind consciousness, a world. So that's why we say why the... Yogacara school is called the consciousness only school or mind only. Everything is simply, all the outer world is simply discriminated, a discriminated world which is created by mind, by consciousness in various ways. It's a very complex study. Peter. Does that mean that seeing and smelling and hearing and tasting and touching are all one thing also? No, they're all different.
[18:55]
Everything is the same and different. Well, they're all one thing, the mind. Well, what is perceived is one thing which is perceived in different ways. I hear you, and I see you, and I smell you, and I taste you, and I touch you. But you're just the one thing. No, they're different. They're different faculties. But, you know, Tozon, when he became enlightened, he said something like... Only when you can see through the ear and hear through the eye will you get it. You got comments about the people who hear bites and smell sound, there's a condition where they've actually been able to test it.
[20:20]
People that'll hear music and they'll see a color and they'll see a color and they'll smell and they'll experience things that way. Maybe related. Maybe related, but I can't say, actually, what that is. Because this is all in the realm of imagination, actually. without getting too complicated, I don't want to get stopped, because there's a lot to talk about here. There's a lot that can be said about every little thing, you know, and investigated about every... So, we have to continue. So, this is the sixth level, mano-vijnana. But mano-vijnana also is a thinking consciousness, thought consciousness, but it's discriminating without being self-centered. So what I'm teaching you is my understanding.
[21:22]
There are lots of different ways of understanding this. And these are the big controversies about it, about the fine points. So I don't want to get into the fine points, but this is my understanding, is that basically, mano-vijnana, mind consciousness, is a discriminating consciousness, but it's not discriminating, it's not an ego consciousness. It's not making judgments based on desire. It's simply making discriminations based on information. Because it has no desire to do anything with the information. Yeah. Speak up. Well, it depends on what kind of feeling you mean. There's touch, which is feeling, and then there's sensations and emotions, which are feeling.
[22:25]
So you have to describe what feeling you mean. You mean the division between good and bad? No, it doesn't make distinctions between good and bad and so forth. It simply records information, as far as my understanding goes. This is the consciousness which identifies information, but it's not making judgments. To clarify, you said that it says, I see and I hear. I didn't say that. You didn't say that? No, I said there's hearing, there is, but that's a good point. I didn't say I hear. I said there is hearing, there is smelling, there is tasting, there is touching. It hasn't reached the level of I yet. When we get to the next consciousness, seventh, that's I here. I see, I smell, I taste, I touch. The seventh consciousness is imagination and volition and all of the trouble that we get into is manas.
[23:34]
All of the ideas that we have are manas. Our thinking mind, our discriminating mind based on self is manas. Manas is ego. That's, so that's the big one. Yeah. No subject yet. The subject is manas. The reason why, manas is also a vijnana. But vijnana means consciousness. That's all. They don't say manas-vijnana because it's too confusing to say manas-vijnana and mano-vijnana. So manas is just, you know, in order to make it easier to distinguish, say manas. And the sixth consciousness is mano-vijnana.
[24:36]
So manas is the appropriating... consciousness. And Manas is based on, it gets all of its information, well it gets, Manas is the step between the first six consciousnesses and the eighth consciousness. Eighth consciousness is called alaya, which is the seed repository of memory. There's many other things, but... Elia is like the store, called storehouse consciousness. All the seeds of our actions are registered. You have a registration, unfortunately. You cannot escape. Even if you blank it out, there's a registration, a registrar, going down on your permanent record?
[25:40]
This goes down on your permanent record. There's a recorder who plants a seed every time you have a thought or an action. And it planted in the ground of Alaya. And when the seeds are watered, they sprout. And it's called habit energy. Or I remember, or... karma, karmic actions, all the karmic actions, all the volitional actions are recorded in the Alaya Vijnana and as seeds for future rebirth. So rebirth, you know, is the two terms. One is reincarnation and the other is rebirth. reincarnation is a little far-fetched, but rebirth is obvious because it doesn't mean that something is reborn, but the action influence of whatever we do creates another action.
[26:56]
Things bump, it's like this. And this is called rebirthing. You had your hand up first. A seed gets planted into a liar when a thought that has some volition behind it. So any thought that is a seventh consciousness, malas-related thought? Well, not necessarily. I think that everything is recorded. So if something is still at the level of just sense consciousness or maybe even just a mind consciousness, it's still planting seeds. But they're not karmic sins, are they? Well, karmic are not. Alaya is neutral. Alaya has no designs on anything. It's simply the bed. So everything is imprinted on the seedbed of aliyah, as far as my understanding goes.
[28:05]
Everything. Some people say, only the bad seeds. Some people say, well, good and bad are both planted. Right? So, maybe for practical purposes, to narrow things down to what's important for us, we can say, that karmic seeds, both good and bad, so to speak, wholesome and unwholesome, are both implanted in alaya and seeds. I think that's more realistic. But you had your hand up first. I was just wondering how it relates to the 12-link communication. Well, you can figure that out later. I mean, it's a good question, but if I go into that, we'll never get through this. I was just reading Transformation at the Base, and in the chapter Transmission talks a lot about how seeds are transmitted from our ancestors and pretty much all of them is transmitted down through us.
[29:16]
That's right. So, there are two categories of seeds. One is the seeds that have been planted in the human race from the first, from the beginning of time, which we all carry. So these are kind of, as far as permanence can be used, the seeds that everyone carries that describe the evolution of our psychophysical being. Well, I don't want to get into DNA, and I don't want to get into genes, but just leaving it on this level,
[30:17]
We are the end product of the whole human race since the beginning of time. We represent the peak of the evolution of human development. Sorry to say. So all of that development is within our alaya vision. All the information and seeds are within that alaya consciousness. And then there are the personal seeds, which are due to our actions right now, from the beginning. But this brings in the idea of Well, when did we start? When I was born, I was born in 1929.
[31:24]
Is that when my Elia began? Well, the idea of birth and death is just an idea because we observe how people come into the world and then how they leave. And we call that birth and death. But according to Buddha Dharma, birth and death are continuous. And they don't, birth doesn't begin with some place beginning in the womb and then ending with the dissolution of the body, the psychophysical entity called me. But life itself is continuous because the only problem we have with birth and death is self.
[32:25]
Right? When there's no self, there's no problem with birth and death. That's really so. The only problem with birth and death is the idea of self. I'm going to lose self. And what is self? Manas. So manas is the big stumbling block. Yeah. I have a question about the two types of seeds, and I was wondering if it... Don't speak to your book. It seems like with the two types of seeds, there would be some things that you can change and some things that you can't change. Yes. You know, in Buddha's time, there were many philosophers... And many of the philosophers held the idea that life was fate. Fate means predetermined.
[33:27]
So in philosophy, there's determination, the determined and the undetermined. Determined means that you're born into this world with certain destiny, or not destiny, but fate, and you're simply working out your fate, which is preordained. Sometimes it seems like that. But actually, this is called determined. Already determined. But Buddha held very strongly that life is not determined. and that you can change your karma anytime. Karma is not fixed. So this is salvation in Buddhism, means that karma is not fixed and that we are self-creating. Human being is self-creating. Within the limits of our environment and our situation and our conditions, we can do whatever we want. and we can create ourself in any way that we want.
[34:35]
And karma is not fixed. Karma is volitional action. And the result of karma is phala. It's fruit, fallout. Phala means fallout. It's the result. of our actions. But we can change our actions. We don't have to continue to follow habit energy slavishly. Because even though it seems like we can't, we can change. It's possible to change. And people do it all the time. So you can change the direction of your volitional actions in any direction you want, even though we may feel enslaved by our feelings, emotions, and mental dispositions.
[35:48]
We're not. We're not enslaved by those. I mean, we are enslaved by them, but we don't have to be. Do you say that's the good side of ego? Say that again. Do you call that the good side of ego? Good side of ego. Well, I'll talk about the good side of ego later. Well, volition, you know, ego is tied in with volition. But volition is not necessarily ego. So, but we do talk about, we keep talking about ego when it's, the way I talk about ego, desire, right? Ego is desire, based on desire. So when desire is turned toward practice, which you would call good, then it's called way-seeking mind.
[36:56]
It's no longer called desire. Because it's... The difference is that desire is... It's the same impulse, but desire is... We call desire the attribute of ego. Or the energy of ego. Whereas waste-eating mind is the energy of... It's desire driven by way-seeking mind rather than driven by ego. When it's driven by ego, it's called desire. And when it's driven by way-seeking mind, by practice, it's called way-seeking mind. They're different, yeah. One is to build the ego and the other is to put it in the right perspective. So that's what you call right, a good ego, right?
[38:01]
You could call that good, the good side of ego would be practice or the desire to bring ego down, bring the puffed up ego down to where it actually works for the benefit of all beings instead of just for itself. Be wise but not popped up. That's right. I thought of that when I was saying that. Yeah. I can't hear what you said. What are the Elias seeds that we can't save? Oh. I don't know. I don't know. I can't tell you that. What? I'm just kidding. I'll probably never be the heavyweight prize-fighting champion of the world.
[39:04]
Is that one of the seats that you wanted to be? Well, you know. The evolutionary kind of seeds that you can't change. Yeah, the evolutionary seeds, I think, are not seeds that we can change, although we can modify them because we are the directors of evolution to a certain extent. Yeah. The idea that we have bodies. The idea that we have bodies. I don't know. It's just too much for me to get into at this point. So, okay, so there's, I just want to kind of explicate
[40:07]
what the eight consciousnesses are doing, without going into it too much. So we have the first five sense consciousnesses, and we have mano-vijnana, which is thinking consciousness, which discriminates between the fields of sense, but is not a self-centered consciousness. And then we have manas, which is self-centered consciousness. This is the consciousness that says, I and me, which appropriates to itself. It's a substitute for being Buddha-centric. It's self-centric. but it's not Buddha-centric. It sees itself as the center instead of Buddha as the center.
[41:10]
So the seventh consciousness, manas, thinks that the alaya is itself. In other words, we think that all the stuff in our memory and our ideas and all the torrent of thoughts Alaya is sometimes described as like a rushing torrent of seeds which are continually sprouting and habit energy and delusion, basically. It's like it holds all the seeds of delusion. And Manas delights in that. It's called Krista Mana.
[42:15]
It's called defiled consciousness, actually, because it's based on delusion. This is the consciousness that's based on delusion. thinking of itself as the person, as the person. And because people are conscious of this, they are conscious of it, so that makes it even more delusional. Krista means defiled. like the clichés, or the defilements. What do you think about? There's something I'm confused about. You said subway, before, and also these things make up for ignorance. How did these things come to us like anything else?
[43:17]
What about these things? It's called consciousness and self-conflict. It's not something that we stumble over. It's just our association with this. I don't remember saying we stumble over it. The ego being the stumbling block. Oh, I said stumbling block. Yeah. It's not something else that just comes to us like anything else. It's just our association. Is it inherently something that we stumble over? It seems to be. Because we've been doing it for so long. You know, you make one mistake, And then when you make one mistake, you kind of think, well, I'll try that again. And you do it again, and you say, well, this feels pretty good. And then you try it again. The third time becomes a habit. No, we're not trying to throw the baby out with the bathwater. We're trying to put the baby where it belongs. Trying to put the baby where it belongs.
[44:43]
So the baby jumps out of the tub and starts taking over. This is the problem with the baby. It jumps out of the tub and starts taking over. When Buddha was a baby, he put one hand in the air, but this baby jumps out of the tub and takes over. I describe this as the office boy, because the amanas has a function, and the function is to send messages between... Takes out the boss's cigar and lights it up and starts ordering everybody around. But he doesn't know what the hell he's doing. And he makes a mess out of everything. And his name is... I said, George Bush. Anyway, so we have to get to, you know, this is like cutting the ego down to size.
[45:55]
and so it can do its proper function without thinking that it's the bots. Yes, all the consciousnesses are Buddha nature. That's right. They're all aspects of Buddha nature. So there's a ninth consciousness, which is not on here, because ninth consciousness is not a discriminating consciousness. It's on the other side of the paper. That's right. It's on the other side of the paper. Thank you for that. And that's what, you know, Suzuki Roshi said, when you... study or hear something in Buddha Dharma, you should read the other side of the page. We say, read between the lines.
[46:59]
But they say, read the other side of the page. But that's right. There's the ninth consciousness. But I'll get to that. So this is kind of like the gist of how consciousness works. So then there's the purification of consciousness. How does consciousness become purified? Because when consciousness is purified, it's called wisdom. It's no longer called vijnana. called wisdom, prajna. So these are the four prajnas, prajna. We say prajna, but P-R-A-G-N-A means, it's easily pronounced, in Hindi it's pronounced prajna, prajna.
[48:04]
Transforming or purifying beads? Transformation, transforming, purifying, yeah. Inverting, purifying, transforming. It's called pratica-samuppada, which means turning at the base. In other words, the whole base turns around. This is sometimes like thinking in a way of sudden enlightenment. It's like when the base turns, everything becomes clear. When one thing turns, everything is turned. So when ego or manas is turned around, so to speak, then alaya becomes purified and the six senses become purified and they have names. So when alaya is purified, it's called the great perfect mirror wisdom.
[49:10]
the jewel mirror, the mirror wisdom, which sees everything as it is, and it becomes the ninth consciousness, which is called amala, A-M-A-L-A, amala consciousness. The seventh consciousness, ego, becomes the wisdom of great equality. In other words, instead of seeing itself as a separate entity, it sees the interconnection of all things. And this is called horizontal. Horizontal means leveling. Everything is on the level. In other words, no one thing is any greater than anything else. But everything is totally one piece before discrimination.
[50:18]
So, manas is the great discriminating consciousness. And when it's purified, it sees the non-discrimination. It sees things in the non-discriminating, with non-discriminating wisdom. It becomes a good boy. Yes. We don't try to make it act like anything. We're not trying to whip anybody into shape. You just let go. When you let go, it fills your hand. You're not trying to get anything because everything is there. All you have to do is let go.
[51:19]
That's why it's a non-gaining practice. Let go of gaining mind. Period. Can you say a little bit more about the proper function of the ego? Well, I'm getting there. The proper function of the ego is to see everything completely as one. See everything as equal. You have to speak up so everybody can hear you, not just me. Amala? Amala, I said, was the ninth. When the eighth consciousness is purified, it's Amala. And that's non-discrimination? That's simplistic. We're always discriminating. Every moment you're discriminating, there's discrimination taking place.
[52:25]
Every moment discrimination takes place. But discrimination is either egotistical discrimination or non-egotistical discrimination. When we talk about discriminating mind, we're not talking about the difference between the book and the microphone. That's discriminating. I mean, you have to discriminate. We're talking about discriminating on the basis of delusive ego. That's what I mean by discrimination. Discriminating on the sense of the delusion of self. So what's the difference between the first two wisdoms? What do you mean by first two? Great mirror and then great equality. Is there a... Well, mirror sees everything as it is without discrimination on the basis of self. The mirror sees... When you pass by a mirror...
[53:29]
When you pass by a mirror, the mirror reflects you. It reflects what it sees that reflects you. It reflects what it sees. When you look into the mirror, you see yourself. But the mirror doesn't see yourself. The mirror just sees things as it is. So when you pass the mirror the first time, when you're walking down the street and you see yourself reflected in the store window, it takes you by surprise and you really see yourself. But then the next moment, you see yourself as you want to see yourself. That's the difference. So to see things really as they are, very hard, because discriminating consciousness, called ego, is always making up a picture of what is. instead of seeing things as they are. This is the problem. So it's very hard to see reality because all we see is our partiality, our picture, discriminating picture based on partiality.
[54:41]
I like this. I don't like that. That's why in Zazen you let go of I like this and I like that. I want this. I want that. You just let go of all that so you can see reality as it is. You may not also, but you have the opportunity. You know, one of the things you might see in the great perfect mirror is you might see, like, oh, look, there's ego again. Oh, look, there's ego again. That's, you know, the mirror will, if you see accurately, without discrimination, you will see ego arising and you recognize it. Whatever is there will be seen as it is. So the great mirror sees everything just as it is. Because there's no self in it. Pure consciousness. Bare awareness. It's called bare awareness.
[55:44]
So zazen is bare awareness. I don't want to say just right, because then we start judging right zazen, wrong zazen. But when zazen is zazen, then there is no one who sees. There's simply seeing sees, hearing hears, and there's no one there. Because it's not my practice, it's Buddha's practice. So zazen is the mirror, wisdom, when discrimination is no longer present. You wouldn't really see ego then, because if you see ego, you just remember anything. You see ego. You don't say ego, that's right, because there's nothing to be seen. That's ego. But... ego does arise.
[56:46]
But then ego is simply just one of the other... sensations or arisings that pass through. It does arise, but you don't say, this is ego. It's just, instead of saying ego, you say, I want or I don't want. That's recognizing ego. So you don't see ego as a figure of some kind or an apparition. It's just, as soon as you say, I don't like this, that's ego. I don't want this, that's ego. Oh, I love this, that's ego. Appropriating, ego arises through clinging and aversion. Clinging and aversion, wanting and aversion. So we become attached to wanting and we become attached to aversion.
[57:49]
And when I first started sitting zazen, Suzuki Roshi used to say, you're attached to the pain in your legs. And I thought, I'm not attached to the pain in my legs. I don't want it. What do you mean I'm attached to it? But then I found out what he meant. We are attached to it. We're attached to pain and we're attached to pleasure. Oh, this is the way it says and should be. And then, uh-oh! So, then when one avijñāna, the sixth consciousness, which is discriminating but not not egotistical, is called the marvelous observing wisdom, subtle observation, meaning that it's just the opposite of equality.
[59:05]
Equality sees everything on a horizontal level without hierarchy. Mano Vijnana sees everything in its hierarchical sense as distinct. In other words, everything is distinct and on a different plane. Hierarchy means one thing is here and another thing is here. And one thing is here and another thing is here. And you see the relationship between all things. Rather than the oneness, you see the differences. as they are. So if you only see oneness, that's not it yet. There has to be oneness and diversity. Well, that's a good point.
[60:07]
It's simply, you know, you could say that absorbing wisdom is in, it's simply no longer called vijnana. It's called wisdom because it's, as Hakuin says, if I can get back to him here, that's, hold on, he says, When the four wisdoms are bound together, right? So when they're bound together, even though sixth consciousness may not need to turn, it's bound up with the other four, and therefore it's called marvelous observing because it's still the observing wisdom.
[61:36]
But although it's the absorbing wisdom, it also thinks. So it's a little bit unclear as to how much... It also has some taintedness to it, because it's associated with the seventh consciousness. In itself, it's not... You know, it's like your body... the buddy of the crook, you know? It's kind of tainted by association, right? So... You also say because it has a purpose at that point... A what? A purpose. Yeah, before it was discriminating because that was fun, and now it's sort of driven by fact that it's driven by a certain realization. Yeah. That's how it's inverted. Yeah. You could say that, I think. Yeah. These eight consciousnesses aren't really distinct from one another. They're all one.
[62:38]
There are eight aspects of one consciousness. As a matter of fact, there are eight aspects of Amala. Because Amala is undivided. And Amala divides itself into eight levels of consciousness in order to... When we're born, so to speak, Amara is like our pure aspect, and then as we enter in the world, it divides itself into eight levels of consciousness. This is not only Buddhist. This is several other religious thinkers have the same similar kind of understanding. Not the same, but similar. Also, modern biology, neurobiology is kind of really bearing it out.
[63:42]
We're getting great book news. My question is, you said that the first and fifth rank were the same? Not the same, no. But in the end, they The first, like, the alaya and the first five or six have the same aspect. I'll do that next time. I'll bring my explanation next time. So, Nayan, the first five sense consciousnesses become the perfection of action wisdom, which means that this is like their function, the function of, that's why it's called nirmanakaya, right?
[64:46]
So if you look at the bodies, the dharmakaya is the essence body. which is the reality body. And alaya is, it's a little unclear exactly, but alaya is associated with the ninth consciousness in particular. And when it's purified, it's like the Dharmakaya. Dharmakaya is, Amala is another name for Dharmakaya. These various names are somewhat the same, but the different ways of looking at it. So it's the reality body, the essence body, and that is Buddha, the mirror. And Sambhogakaya is wisdom body, which is Manas, right? Manas becomes, instead of becoming ego, becomes wisdom, the wisdom of universal nature.
[65:51]
and which is called the enjoyment body, you know, because then true joy arises. It's also called the reward body because it's when one is enlightened, which means giving up, basically, letting go, then it's the reward body. And so that's wisdom, and that's sambhogakaya. So that's your sambhogakaya. Sambhogakaya is not something out there, it's you. Your three bodies are your own bodies. Your Buddha body, your wisdom body, and your nirmanakaya body, which means your functioning body, which is your sensory life. Our life is totally sensory. So in that sensory life, your life is motivated through wisdom rather than through desire, so to speak.
[67:06]
Maybe it's the desire of wisdom, as you call it, way-seeking mind. So this is the purification of consciousness. the various levels of consciousness become purified and become wisdom bodies. So all of your actions are, all of our actions are actions which are activated or channeled into action. So our actions become motivated by or informed and motivated by the other three wisdoms. So that's the basis. And then they relate to the five ranks, which we'll go into later.
[68:07]
We have more classes. I have some other handouts, but I'll give them to you next time? No, I'll give them to you now. No, I have to say that Zen does not have any particular teachings. Sorry. But we teach Buddhist understanding according to the Zen way of doing things. It's more like hinting. But, so we appropriate from other traditions. Now the Shingon tradition, or the Vajrayana, Shingon is Japanese, Vajrayana is Indian, but they're the same school.
[69:16]
And it's the esoteric school, the kind of mystery school, the school of the two mandalas, the vaja mandala and the womb mandala, the tanagdagarbha, which I don't want to get into. But actually, all of this comes from that. My Zumi Roshi likes to call it the experiential and intrinsic. I like those terms. Intrinsic is like the dark, and experiential is like the light. The light side is our life we think of as experiential. But the other side is always there.
[70:24]
What I'm going to hand out to you is a kind of Vajrayana example. This is from one of the mandalas. And it's about the eight consciousnesses. It gives you an outline of the eight consciousnesses and where Vairochana fits into this. Because Vairochana is like the ninth consciousness, Amala. Pure Dharmakaya. Vairochana Buddha, pure Dharmakaya. Same thing. Same thing as saying amalala consciousness. And vairacana is like the center of the universe. A way of anthropomorphizing this figure as the center of the universe and emanates.
[71:34]
Right? Everything's emanated from. So this is as close as... Buddhism gets to a deity, but Vajrayana is denied as a deity. Anyway, this might be of interest to you, because the mandala of the four Buddhas, of the four directions and the four bodhisattvas, And the nomenclature may be a little off that I wrote in there, but it's pretty much the same. So you can take this and ponder it. And if you have any leftovers, I would like some. I'm either one of these. Do I have any leftovers of this? Maybe not. I got one for Leslie.
[72:37]
Oh, that's okay. Okay. So next time we'll talk more about the five ranks. and go on with Hakuin's commentary. But in order to understand what he's talking about, we have to understand this. And this is called Transformation at the Base. This is a book that was put together, Thich Nhat Hanh's talks about all of this. And this should be required reading. for all Zen students who have any education at all.
[73:42]
You don't have to have a lot of education. You can start reading it. But called Transformation of Debates, 50 Verses on the Nature of Consciousness. And a little commentary. And the more you read it, the more you will want to read it. Do you know what Lhouchana Buddha is? Who Buddha? Lhouchana Buddha. Yeah. Lhouchana Buddha is Amitabha. Amida Buddha is Lhouchana Buddha. Okay.
[74:49]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_84.28